Skip to main content
. 2020 Jan 21;46(3):383–400. doi: 10.1007/s00134-019-05872-y

Table 4.

QUADAS-2 risk of bias assessment per setting

Paper Setting Risk of bias
Patient selection Index test Reference standard Flow and timing Data management
ED Horng et al. [35] Sepsis graphic file with name 134_2019_5872_Figa_HTML.gif graphic file with name 134_2019_5872_Figa_HTML.gif ? graphic file with name 134_2019_5872_Figa_HTML.gif graphic file with name 134_2019_5872_Figa_HTML.gif
Haug et al. [62] Sepsis graphic file with name 134_2019_5872_Figb_HTML.gif graphic file with name 134_2019_5872_Figa_HTML.gif ? graphic file with name 134_2019_5872_Figa_HTML.gif graphic file with name 134_2019_5872_Figb_HTML.gif
Delahanty et al. [63] Sepsis graphic file with name 134_2019_5872_Figa_HTML.gif graphic file with name 134_2019_5872_Figa_HTML.gif ? graphic file with name 134_2019_5872_Figa_HTML.gif graphic file with name 134_2019_5872_Figa_HTML.gif
Brown et al. [28] Severe sepsis and septic shock graphic file with name 134_2019_5872_Figa_HTML.gif graphic file with name 134_2019_5872_Figb_HTML.gif ? graphic file with name 134_2019_5872_Figa_HTML.gif graphic file with name 134_2019_5872_Figa_HTML.gif
In-hospital Khojandi et al. [64] Sepsis graphic file with name 134_2019_5872_Figa_HTML.gif graphic file with name 134_2019_5872_Figa_HTML.gif ? graphic file with name 134_2019_5872_Figa_HTML.gif graphic file with name 134_2019_5872_Figa_HTML.gif
Futoma et al. [65] Sepsis graphic file with name 134_2019_5872_Figb_HTML.gif graphic file with name 134_2019_5872_Figa_HTML.gif ? graphic file with name 134_2019_5872_Figa_HTML.gif graphic file with name 134_2019_5872_Figb_HTML.gif
McCoy et al. [31] Severe sepsis, Sepsis graphic file with name 134_2019_5872_Figb_HTML.gif graphic file with name 134_2019_5872_Figb_HTML.gif ? graphic file with name 134_2019_5872_Figa_HTML.gif graphic file with name 134_2019_5872_Figa_HTML.gif
Lin et al. [66] Septic shock graphic file with name 134_2019_5872_Figb_HTML.gif graphic file with name 134_2019_5872_Figa_HTML.gif ? graphic file with name 134_2019_5872_Figa_HTML.gif graphic file with name 134_2019_5872_Figa_HTML.gif
Khoshnevisan et al. [14] Septic shock graphic file with name 134_2019_5872_Figb_HTML.gif graphic file with name 134_2019_5872_Figa_HTML.gif ? graphic file with name 134_2019_5872_Figa_HTML.gif graphic file with name 134_2019_5872_Figa_HTML.gif
Thiel et al. [29] Septic shock graphic file with name 134_2019_5872_Figb_HTML.gif graphic file with name 134_2019_5872_Figa_HTML.gif ? graphic file with name 134_2019_5872_Figa_HTML.gif graphic file with name 134_2019_5872_Figa_HTML.gif
Giannini et al. [30] Severe sepsis and septic shock graphic file with name 134_2019_5872_Figa_HTML.gif graphic file with name 134_2019_5872_Figa_HTML.gif ? graphic file with name 134_2019_5872_Figa_HTML.gif graphic file with name 134_2019_5872_Figa_HTML.gif
ICU Wang et al. [57] Sepsis graphic file with name 134_2019_5872_Figb_HTML.gif graphic file with name 134_2019_5872_Figa_HTML.gif ? graphic file with name 134_2019_5872_Figa_HTML.gif graphic file with name 134_2019_5872_Figa_HTML.gif
Shashikumar II et al. [67] Sepsis graphic file with name 134_2019_5872_Figb_HTML.gif graphic file with name 134_2019_5872_Figa_HTML.gif ? graphic file with name 134_2019_5872_Figa_HTML.gif graphic file with name 134_2019_5872_Figb_HTML.gif
Shashikumar I et al. [68] Sepsis graphic file with name 134_2019_5872_Figa_HTML.gif graphic file with name 134_2019_5872_Figa_HTML.gif ? graphic file with name 134_2019_5872_Figa_HTML.gif graphic file with name 134_2019_5872_Figb_HTML.gif
Scherpf et al. [59] Sepsis graphic file with name 134_2019_5872_Figb_HTML.gif graphic file with name 134_2019_5872_Figa_HTML.gif ? graphic file with name 134_2019_5872_Figa_HTML.gif graphic file with name 134_2019_5872_Figa_HTML.gif
Desautels et al. [54] Sepsis graphic file with name 134_2019_5872_Figa_HTML.gif graphic file with name 134_2019_5872_Figa_HTML.gif ? graphic file with name 134_2019_5872_Figa_HTML.gif graphic file with name 134_2019_5872_Figa_HTML.gif
Nemati et al. [55] Sepsis graphic file with name 134_2019_5872_Figa_HTML.gif graphic file with name 134_2019_5872_Figa_HTML.gif ? graphic file with name 134_2019_5872_Figa_HTML.gif graphic file with name 134_2019_5872_Figa_HTML.gif
Calvert II et al. [52] Sepsis graphic file with name 134_2019_5872_Figb_HTML.gif graphic file with name 134_2019_5872_Figb_HTML.gif ? graphic file with name 134_2019_5872_Figa_HTML.gif graphic file with name 134_2019_5872_Figa_HTML.gif
Kam et al. [53] Sepsis graphic file with name 134_2019_5872_Figb_HTML.gif graphic file with name 134_2019_5872_Figa_HTML.gif ? graphic file with name 134_2019_5872_Figa_HTML.gif graphic file with name 134_2019_5872_Figa_HTML.gif
Van Wyk I et al. [69] Sepsis graphic file with name 134_2019_5872_Figb_HTML.gif graphic file with name 134_2019_5872_Figa_HTML.gif ? graphic file with name 134_2019_5872_Figa_HTML.gif graphic file with name 134_2019_5872_Figa_HTML.gif
Van Wyk II et al. [70] Sepsis graphic file with name 134_2019_5872_Figb_HTML.gif graphic file with name 134_2019_5872_Figa_HTML.gif ? graphic file with name 134_2019_5872_Figa_HTML.gif graphic file with name 134_2019_5872_Figa_HTML.gif
Moss et al. [36] Severe sepsis graphic file with name 134_2019_5872_Figa_HTML.gif graphic file with name 134_2019_5872_Figb_HTML.gif ? graphic file with name 134_2019_5872_Figa_HTML.gif graphic file with name 134_2019_5872_Figa_HTML.gif
Guillén et al. [58] Severe sepsis graphic file with name 134_2019_5872_Figb_HTML.gif graphic file with name 134_2019_5872_Figa_HTML.gif ? graphic file with name 134_2019_5872_Figa_HTML.gif graphic file with name 134_2019_5872_Figa_HTML.gif
Shimabukuro et al. [32] Severe sepsis graphic file with name 134_2019_5872_Figb_HTML.gif graphic file with name 134_2019_5872_Figb_HTML.gif ? graphic file with name 134_2019_5872_Figa_HTML.gif graphic file with name 134_2019_5872_Figa_HTML.gif
Henry et al. [56] Septic shock graphic file with name 134_2019_5872_Figa_HTML.gif graphic file with name 134_2019_5872_Figa_HTML.gif ? graphic file with name 134_2019_5872_Figa_HTML.gif graphic file with name 134_2019_5872_Figa_HTML.gif
Calvert I et al. [33] Septic shock graphic file with name 134_2019_5872_Figb_HTML.gif graphic file with name 134_2019_5872_Figa_HTML.gif ? graphic file with name 134_2019_5872_Figa_HTML.gif graphic file with name 134_2019_5872_Figa_HTML.gif
ED/In-hospital/ICU Barton et al. [27] Sepsis graphic file with name 134_2019_5872_Figa_HTML.gif graphic file with name 134_2019_5872_Figa_HTML.gif ? graphic file with name 134_2019_5872_Figa_HTML.gif graphic file with name 134_2019_5872_Figa_HTML.gif
Mao et al. [71] Sepsis, severe sepsis, septic shock graphic file with name 134_2019_5872_Figa_HTML.gif graphic file with name 134_2019_5872_Figa_HTML.gif ? graphic file with name 134_2019_5872_Figa_HTML.gif graphic file with name 134_2019_5872_Figa_HTML.gif

Inline graphic  low risk, Inline graphic  high risk, ? unclear risk