Skip to main content
. 2016 May 13;2016(5):CD012183. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD012183
Radiographic: Mean Difference for All Treatments
Treatment Reference MD (95% Crl)
MTX + DMARD MTX ‐5.72 (‐13.53,2.31)
SD ETN SC   ‐4.32 (‐11.12,2.40)
SD INF IV + MTX   ‐6.43 (‐13.22,‐0.37)
SD ADA SC + MTX   ‐2.60 (‐8.84,3.59)
SD CERTO SC + MTX   ‐0.99 (‐7.19,5.21)
SD ABA SC + MTX   ‐2.38 (‐11.26,6.33)
SD ETN SC + MTX   ‐6.10 (‐12.86,0.67)
LD ADA SC + MTX   ‐1.90 (‐8.14,4.30)
LD CERTO SC + MTX   0.14 (‐195.40,196.50)
HD CERTO SC + MTX   ‐1.61 (‐7.78,4.60)
HD INF IV + MTX   ‐6.75 (‐13.30,‐1.60)
SD ETN SC MTX + DMARD 1.39 (‐9.06,11.60)
SD INF IV + MTX   ‐0.64 (‐5.79,3.47)
SD ADA SC + MTX   3.15 (‐7.06,13.06)
SD CERTO SC + MTX   4.75 (‐5.35,14.56)
SD ABA SC + MTX   3.37 (‐8.61,15.01)
SD ETN SC + MTX   ‐0.37 (‐10.79,9.83)
LD ADA SC + MTX   3.86 (‐6.37,13.74)
LD CERTO SC + MTX   5.70 (‐189.80,202.20)
HD CERTO SC + MTX   4.15 (‐5.93,13.98)
HD INF IV + MTX   ‐0.99 (‐9.73,5.92)
SD INF IV + MTX SD ETN SC ‐2.09 (‐11.71,6.86)
SD ADA SC + MTX   1.75 (‐7.44,10.93)
SD CERTO SC + MTX   3.32 (‐5.79,12.55)
SD ABA SC + MTX   1.94 (‐9.10,12.98)
SD ETN SC + MTX   ‐1.76 (‐8.05,4.61)
LD ADA SC + MTX   2.42 (‐6.76,11.69)
LD CERTO SC + MTX   4.46 (‐191.10,201.20)
HD CERTO SC + MTX   2.71 (‐6.46,11.95)
HD INF IV + MTX   ‐2.44 (‐12.06,5.83)
SD ADA SC + MTX SD INF IV + MTX 3.82 (‐4.77,13.13)
SD CERTO SC + MTX   5.42 (‐3.08,14.65)
SD ABA SC + MTX   4.02 (‐6.50,15.27)
SD ETN SC + MTX   0.32 (‐8.55,9.91)
LD ADA SC + MTX   4.51 (‐4.05,13.80)
LD CERTO SC + MTX   6.50 (‐189.00,203.10)
HD CERTO SC + MTX   4.80 (‐3.70,14.05)
HD INF IV + MTX   ‐0.30 (‐7.03,5.57)
SD CERTO SC + MTX SD ADA SC + MTX 1.59 (‐7.15,10.45)
SD ABA SC + MTX   0.20 (‐5.96,6.42)
SD ETN SC + MTX   ‐3.49 (‐12.60,5.71)
LD ADA SC + MTX   0.69 (‐5.44,6.93)
LD CERTO SC + MTX   2.74 (‐193.00,199.40)
HD CERTO SC + MTX   0.98 (‐7.83,9.81)
HD INF IV + MTX   ‐4.11 (‐13.28,3.62)
SD ABA SC + MTX SD CERTO SC + MTX ‐1.39 (‐12.21,9.28)
SD ETN SC + MTX   ‐5.10 (‐14.26,4.11)
LD ADA SC + MTX   ‐0.89 (‐9.76,7.88)
LD CERTO SC + MTX   1.14 (‐194.50,197.60)
HD CERTO SC + MTX   ‐0.61 (‐6.82,5.60)
HD INF IV + MTX   ‐5.70 (‐14.95,1.96)
SD ETN SC + MTX SD ABA SC + MTX ‐3.69 (‐14.76,7.32)
LD ADA SC + MTX   0.50 (‐8.19,9.33)
LD CERTO SC + MTX   2.40 (‐193.40,199.20)
HD CERTO SC + MTX   0.78 (‐9.91,11.55)
HD INF IV + MTX   ‐4.29 (‐15.50,5.40)
LD ADA SC + MTX SD ETN SC + MTX 4.19 (‐4.98,13.39)
LD CERTO SC + MTX   6.34 (‐189.20,202.80)
HD CERTO SC + MTX   4.49 (‐4.69,13.62)
HD INF IV + MTX   ‐0.66 (‐10.28,7.52)
LD CERTO SC + MTX LD ADA SC + MTX 2.08 (‐193.40,198.80)
HD CERTO SC + MTX   0.28 (‐8.50,9.11)
HD INF IV + MTX   ‐4.81 (‐14.08,2.90)
HD CERTO SC + MTX LD CERTO SC + MTX ‐1.79 (‐198.40,193.90)
HD INF IV + MTX   ‐6.93 (‐203.50,188.50)
HD INF IV + MTX HD CERTO SC + MTX ‐5.07 (‐14.33,2.54)
     
Random‐Effect Model Total Residual Deviance 20.57 vs 20 data points
  Deviance Information Criteria 52.379
Fixed‐Effect Model Total Residual Deviance 23.04 vs 20 data points
  Deviance Information Criteria 53.62
Note:    
     
Total Patients 3267  
Total Studies 8  
2‐arm 4  
3‐arm 4