Skip to main content
. 2016 May 13;2016(5):CD012183. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD012183
SAEs, Short trial duration, Network 1: Odds Ratios, Risk Ratios and Risk Difference for All Treatment Comparisons‐Random Effects Model
Treatment Reference OR (95% CrI) RR (95% CrI) RD % (95% Crl)
DMARD + PL PL 0.96 (0.14,6.18) 0.96 (0.15,5.17) 0.00 (‐0.04,0.15)
MTX + DMARD   0.93 (0.06,13.23) 0.93 (0.06,9.40) 0.00 (‐0.04,0.28)
SD ADA SC   1.11 (0.59,2.11) 1.11 (0.60,2.04) 0.00 (‐0.02,0.04)
SD ETN SC   1.62 (0.21,13.99) 1.58 (0.22,9.90) 0.02 (‐0.03,0.29)
SD TOC IV + PL SC   1.27 (0.41,3.80) 1.26 (0.42,3.48) 0.01 (‐0.02,0.09)
SD TOFA PO   0.39 (0.14,1.05) 0.40 (0.14,1.05) ‐0.02 (‐0.04,0.00)
SD CERTO SC   4.43 (1.10,21.91) 3.94 (1.10,13.92) 0.10 (0.00,0.37)
SD TOC SC + PL IV   1.10 (0.26,4.60) 1.09 (0.27,4.06) 0.00 (‐0.03,0.11)
SD ETN SC + MTX   1.66 (0.15,21.12) 1.62 (0.16,13.16) 0.02 (‐0.04,0.38)
SD ETN SC + DMARD   1.45 (0.29,6.57) 1.42 (0.30,5.47) 0.01 (‐0.03,0.16)
SD ADA SC + DMARD   0.67 (0.08,5.30) 0.68 (0.08,4.61) ‐0.01 (‐0.04,0.13)
SD ANA + DMARD   0.95 (0.12,7.22) 0.95 (0.12,5.96) 0.00 (‐0.04,0.18)
SD CERTO SC + DMARD   0.66 (0.06,6.85) 0.67 (0.06,5.67) ‐0.01 (‐0.04,0.17)
SD TOCI SC + DMARD   1.25 (0.14,10.79) 1.23 (0.14,8.01) 0.01 (‐0.04,0.25)
LD ADA SC   0.65 (0.25,1.49) 0.66 (0.26,1.47) ‐0.01 (‐0.03,0.02)
HD TOFA PO   0.53 (0.22,1.37) 0.54 (0.22,1.35) ‐0.02 (‐0.04,0.01)
HD ADA SC   1.00 (0.45,2.30) 1.00 (0.46,2.21) 0.00 (‐0.02,0.04)
HD TOCI IV + DMARD   1.47 (0.20,10.44) 1.45 (0.21,7.81) 0.02 (‐0.03,0.25)
MTX + DMARD DMARD + PL 0.91 (0.04,25.54) 0.91 (0.04,19.57) 0.00 (‐0.15,0.27)
SD ADA SC   1.18 (0.20,7.16) 1.18 (0.24,6.85) 0.01 (‐0.14,0.05)
SD ETN SC   1.63 (0.11,29.72) 1.59 (0.13,22.57) 0.02 (‐0.13,0.28)
SD TOC IV + PL SC   1.34 (0.18,10.39) 1.33 (0.21,9.65) 0.01 (‐0.13,0.09)
SD TOFA PO   0.40 (0.04,3.31) 0.41 (0.05,3.25) ‐0.02 (‐0.18,0.02)
SD CERTO SC   4.76 (0.43,57.12) 4.15 (0.49,40.20) 0.10 (‐0.08,0.37)
SD TOC SC + PL IV   1.18 (0.14,10.56) 1.17 (0.16,9.81) 0.00 (‐0.14,0.10)
SD ETN SC + MTX   1.71 (0.09,40.13) 1.65 (0.10,28.01) 0.02 (‐0.12,0.37)
SD ETN SC + DMARD   1.52 (0.57,4.02) 1.48 (0.60,3.82) 0.01 (‐0.04,0.08)
SD ADA SC + DMARD   0.70 (0.25,1.88) 0.71 (0.26,1.80) ‐0.01 (‐0.07,0.04)
SD ANA + DMARD   1.00 (0.42,2.36) 1.00 (0.44,2.21) 0.00 (‐0.04,0.07)
SD CERTO SC + DMARD   0.69 (0.15,2.76) 0.71 (0.16,2.55) ‐0.01 (‐0.08,0.08)
SD TOCI SC + DMARD   1.29 (0.46,4.02) 1.28 (0.47,3.50) 0.01 (‐0.03,0.15)
LD ADA SC   0.68 (0.09,5.06) 0.69 (0.11,4.90) ‐0.01 (‐0.16,0.03)
HD TOFA PO   0.56 (0.06,4.78) 0.57 (0.08,4.64) ‐0.01 (‐0.17,0.03)
HD ADA SC   1.04 (0.16,7.57) 1.04 (0.19,7.26) 0.00 (‐0.15,0.05)
HD TOCI IV + DMARD   1.52 (0.81,2.99) 1.48 (0.82,2.76) 0.01 (‐0.01,0.12)
SD ADA SC MTX + DMARD 1.22 (0.08,20.81) 1.21 (0.11,19.91) 0.01 (‐0.27,0.06)
SD ETN SC   1.76 (0.38,9.71) 1.68 (0.44,9.08) 0.02 (‐0.11,0.15)
SD TOC IV + PL SC   1.39 (0.08,26.66) 1.37 (0.11,24.75) 0.01 (‐0.26,0.10)
SD TOFA PO   0.42 (0.02,8.11) 0.43 (0.03,7.96) ‐0.02 (‐0.30,0.02)
SD CERTO SC   4.76 (0.23,123.50) 4.17 (0.30,86.98) 0.10 (‐0.19,0.37)
SD TOC SC + PL IV   1.22 (0.06,26.45) 1.21 (0.08,24.20) 0.01 (‐0.26,0.11)
SD ETN SC + MTX   1.81 (0.63,6.63) 1.73 (0.66,6.05) 0.02 (‐0.04,0.18)
SD ETN SC + DMARD   1.64 (0.07,34.32) 1.60 (0.10,30.75) 0.02 (‐0.25,0.16)
SD ADA SC + DMARD   0.74 (0.02,20.69) 0.75 (0.03,18.63) ‐0.01 (‐0.28,0.13)
SD ANA + DMARD   1.12 (0.04,27.80) 1.12 (0.05,24.55) 0.00 (‐0.27,0.17)
SD CERTO SC + DMARD   0.74 (0.02,25.08) 0.75 (0.02,21.69) ‐0.01 (‐0.28,0.17)
SD TOCI SC + DMARD   1.44 (0.04,39.90) 1.41 (0.05,33.84) 0.01 (‐0.26,0.24)
LD ADA SC   0.69 (0.04,12.56) 0.70 (0.06,12.17) ‐0.01 (‐0.29,0.04)
HD TOFA PO   0.58 (0.03,10.77) 0.59 (0.05,10.42) ‐0.01 (‐0.29,0.03)
HD ADA SC   1.09 (0.07,21.03) 1.08 (0.09,19.95) 0.00 (‐0.28,0.06)
HD TOCI IV + DMARD   1.68 (0.06,42.31) 1.64 (0.08,35.79) 0.02 (‐0.25,0.24)
SD ETN SC SD ADA SC 1.47 (0.17,13.61) 1.44 (0.17,9.75) 0.02 (‐0.05,0.28)
SD TOC IV + PL SC   1.14 (0.45,2.86) 1.13 (0.46,2.66) 0.00 (‐0.02,0.07)
SD TOFA PO   0.35 (0.10,1.12) 0.36 (0.11,1.12) ‐0.02 (‐0.06,0.00)
SD CERTO SC   3.98 (0.83,23.16) 3.55 (0.84,14.95) 0.10 (‐0.01,0.37)
SD TOC SC + PL IV   0.99 (0.28,3.51) 1.00 (0.28,3.18) 0.00 (‐0.04,0.09)
SD ETN SC + MTX   1.50 (0.12,19.86) 1.47 (0.13,12.19) 0.02 (‐0.05,0.38)
SD ETN SC + DMARD   1.31 (0.30,5.28) 1.29 (0.31,4.51) 0.01 (‐0.03,0.15)
SD ADA SC + DMARD   0.60 (0.08,4.43) 0.61 (0.08,3.83) ‐0.01 (‐0.05,0.12)
SD ANA + DMARD   0.85 (0.12,6.02) 0.85 (0.12,4.95) ‐0.01 (‐0.05,0.17)
SD CERTO SC + DMARD   0.58 (0.06,5.65) 0.59 (0.06,4.77) ‐0.01 (‐0.05,0.16)
SD TOCI SC + DMARD   1.11 (0.14,8.73) 1.10 (0.14,6.65) 0.00 (‐0.04,0.23)
LD ADA SC   0.58 (0.23,1.32) 0.59 (0.24,1.30) ‐0.02 (‐0.05,0.01)
HD TOFA PO   0.47 (0.16,1.47) 0.49 (0.16,1.44) ‐0.02 (‐0.06,0.01)
HD ADA SC   0.90 (0.41,1.99) 0.90 (0.42,1.93) 0.00 (‐0.03,0.03)
HD TOCI IV + DMARD   1.31 (0.20,8.63) 1.29 (0.20,6.50) 0.01 (‐0.04,0.24)
SD TOC IV + PL SC SD ETN SC 0.76 (0.07,7.99) 0.77 (0.10,7.32) ‐0.01 (‐0.28,0.09)
SD TOFA PO   0.23 (0.02,2.47) 0.25 (0.03,2.43) ‐0.04 (‐0.31,0.01)
SD CERTO SC   2.71 (0.21,39.52) 2.44 (0.27,27.00) 0.07 (‐0.21,0.36)
SD TOC SC + PL IV   0.66 (0.05,7.95) 0.67 (0.07,7.18) ‐0.02 (‐0.28,0.10)
SD ETN SC + MTX   1.04 (0.33,3.10) 1.03 (0.35,2.65) 0.00 (‐0.07,0.16)
SD ETN SC + DMARD   0.90 (0.06,11.09) 0.91 (0.09,9.54) 0.00 (‐0.27,0.15)
SD ADA SC + DMARD   0.42 (0.02,7.51) 0.44 (0.03,6.63) ‐0.03 (‐0.29,0.11)
SD ANA + DMARD   0.60 (0.03,9.77) 0.62 (0.04,8.48) ‐0.02 (‐0.28,0.15)
SD CERTO SC + DMARD   0.41 (0.02,9.20) 0.42 (0.02,7.82) ‐0.03 (‐0.29,0.15)
SD TOCI SC + DMARD   0.78 (0.04,14.46) 0.79 (0.04,11.43) ‐0.01 (‐0.27,0.22)
LD ADA SC   0.39 (0.04,3.55) 0.41 (0.05,3.45) ‐0.03 (‐0.30,0.03)
HD TOFA PO   0.32 (0.03,3.15) 0.33 (0.05,3.09) ‐0.04 (‐0.30,0.02)
HD ADA SC   0.60 (0.06,5.72) 0.62 (0.09,5.48) ‐0.02 (‐0.29,0.05)
HD TOCI IV + DMARD   0.94 (0.05,14.51) 0.94 (0.06,11.74) 0.00 (‐0.27,0.21)
SD TOFA PO SD TOC IV + PL SC 0.31 (0.07,1.32) 0.32 (0.07,1.31) ‐0.03 (‐0.11,0.01)
SD CERTO SC   3.51 (0.60,25.56) 3.13 (0.62,17.15) 0.09 (‐0.03,0.36)
SD TOC SC + PL IV   0.87 (0.37,2.09) 0.88 (0.38,1.98) 0.00 (‐0.04,0.05)
SD ETN SC + MTX   1.35 (0.10,19.89) 1.33 (0.10,12.73) 0.01 (‐0.09,0.36)
SD ETN SC + DMARD   1.14 (0.20,6.39) 1.14 (0.21,5.47) 0.01 (‐0.07,0.15)
SD ADA SC + DMARD   0.53 (0.05,4.81) 0.54 (0.06,4.23) ‐0.02 (‐0.10,0.11)
SD ANA + DMARD   0.75 (0.08,6.39) 0.76 (0.09,5.39) ‐0.01 (‐0.09,0.16)
SD CERTO SC + DMARD   0.51 (0.04,5.99) 0.53 (0.05,5.09) ‐0.02 (‐0.10,0.15)
SD TOCI SC + DMARD   0.97 (0.10,9.56) 0.98 (0.11,7.46) 0.00 (‐0.08,0.23)
LD ADA SC   0.51 (0.14,1.74) 0.52 (0.15,1.71) ‐0.02 (‐0.10,0.01)
HD TOFA PO   0.42 (0.10,1.83) 0.43 (0.11,1.81) ‐0.02 (‐0.11,0.01)
HD ADA SC   0.79 (0.24,2.69) 0.80 (0.26,2.60) ‐0.01 (‐0.08,0.04)
HD TOCI IV + DMARD   1.15 (0.14,8.99) 1.14 (0.15,7.16) 0.01 (‐0.08,0.23)
SD CERTO SC SD TOFA PO 11.21 (2.11,79.76) 9.71 (2.05,51.52) 0.12 (0.02,0.39)
SD TOC SC + PL IV   2.80 (0.52,16.83) 2.72 (0.52,14.73) 0.02 (‐0.01,0.13)
SD ETN SC + MTX   4.42 (0.32,64.65) 4.20 (0.33,40.39) 0.04 (‐0.02,0.40)
SD ETN SC + DMARD   3.74 (0.58,23.89) 3.59 (0.58,19.88) 0.04 (‐0.01,0.19)
SD ADA SC + DMARD   1.74 (0.17,18.47) 1.72 (0.17,15.85) 0.01 (‐0.02,0.15)
SD ANA + DMARD   2.46 (0.25,25.78) 2.40 (0.26,20.60) 0.02 (‐0.02,0.21)
SD CERTO SC + DMARD   1.69 (0.12,22.75) 1.67 (0.12,18.34) 0.01 (‐0.02,0.19)
SD TOCI SC + DMARD   3.20 (0.29,36.23) 3.09 (0.30,26.52) 0.03 (‐0.02,0.27)
LD ADA SC   1.65 (0.45,6.49) 1.64 (0.46,6.22) 0.01 (‐0.02,0.04)
HD TOFA PO   1.36 (0.51,3.82) 1.35 (0.52,3.74) 0.00 (‐0.01,0.03)
HD ADA SC   2.53 (0.75,9.86) 2.47 (0.75,9.32) 0.02 (‐0.01,0.07)
HD TOCI IV + DMARD   3.79 (0.42,38.62) 3.63 (0.42,28.27) 0.04 (‐0.01,0.27)
SD TOC SC + PL IV SD CERTO SC 0.25 (0.03,1.75) 0.28 (0.04,1.65) ‐0.10 (‐0.36,0.04)
SD ETN SC + MTX   0.38 (0.02,6.87) 0.42 (0.03,4.60) ‐0.07 (‐0.35,0.30)
SD ETN SC + DMARD   0.32 (0.03,2.65) 0.36 (0.05,2.36) ‐0.08 (‐0.35,0.09)
SD ADA SC + DMARD   0.15 (0.01,1.89) 0.17 (0.01,1.76) ‐0.11 (‐0.37,0.06)
SD ANA + DMARD   0.21 (0.01,2.69) 0.24 (0.02,2.33) ‐0.10 (‐0.37,0.10)
SD CERTO SC + DMARD   0.15 (0.01,2.31) 0.17 (0.01,2.09) ‐0.11 (‐0.37,0.09)
SD TOCI SC + DMARD   0.28 (0.02,3.62) 0.32 (0.03,2.96) ‐0.09 (‐0.36,0.16)
LD ADA SC   0.14 (0.02,0.73) 0.17 (0.03,0.74) ‐0.12 (‐0.38,‐0.01)
HD TOFA PO   0.12 (0.02,0.68) 0.14 (0.03,0.69) ‐0.12 (‐0.38,‐0.01)
HD ADA SC   0.22 (0.03,1.18) 0.25 (0.05,1.17) ‐0.10 (‐0.37,0.01)
HD TOCI IV + DMARD   0.32 (0.02,3.90) 0.36 (0.03,3.14) ‐0.08 (‐0.35,0.17)
SD ETN SC + MTX SD TOC SC + PL IV 1.57 (0.10,26.25) 1.53 (0.11,17.17) 0.02 (‐0.10,0.37)
SD ETN SC + DMARD   1.31 (0.19,8.95) 1.29 (0.21,7.69) 0.01 (‐0.09,0.15)
SD ADA SC + DMARD   0.61 (0.05,6.35) 0.62 (0.06,5.57) ‐0.01 (‐0.11,0.11)
SD ANA + DMARD   0.86 (0.08,8.52) 0.87 (0.09,7.35) 0.00 (‐0.10,0.17)
SD CERTO SC + DMARD   0.59 (0.04,8.07) 0.60 (0.05,6.79) ‐0.01 (‐0.11,0.16)
SD TOCI SC + DMARD   1.11 (0.10,12.81) 1.10 (0.11,10.24) 0.00 (‐0.10,0.23)
LD ADA SC   0.58 (0.12,2.68) 0.59 (0.14,2.61) ‐0.01 (‐0.12,0.02)
HD TOFA PO   0.48 (0.09,2.65) 0.49 (0.10,2.59) ‐0.02 (‐0.13,0.02)
HD ADA SC   0.91 (0.21,4.07) 0.91 (0.23,3.91) 0.00 (‐0.10,0.04)
HD TOCI IV + DMARD   1.30 (0.14,12.44) 1.28 (0.15,9.98) 0.01 (‐0.09,0.23)
SD ETN SC + DMARD SD ETN SC + MTX 0.87 (0.05,14.52) 0.88 (0.07,12.70) ‐0.01 (‐0.36,0.14)
SD ADA SC + DMARD   0.40 (0.02,8.85) 0.42 (0.02,8.05) ‐0.03 (‐0.38,0.11)
SD ANA + DMARD   0.58 (0.02,11.97) 0.60 (0.03,10.31) ‐0.02 (‐0.37,0.15)
SD CERTO SC + DMARD   0.40 (0.01,10.37) 0.42 (0.02,8.96) ‐0.03 (‐0.38,0.14)
SD TOCI SC + DMARD   0.75 (0.03,17.16) 0.76 (0.04,13.90) ‐0.01 (‐0.36,0.21)
LD ADA SC   0.37 (0.03,4.99) 0.39 (0.04,4.85) ‐0.03 (‐0.39,0.03)
HD TOFA PO   0.31 (0.02,4.21) 0.33 (0.04,4.10) ‐0.04 (‐0.39,0.02)
HD ADA SC   0.60 (0.04,7.95) 0.61 (0.07,7.59) ‐0.02 (‐0.38,0.05)
HD TOCI IV + DMARD   0.90 (0.04,17.66) 0.91 (0.05,14.64) 0.00 (‐0.36,0.21)
SD ADA SC + DMARD SD ETN SC + DMARD 0.47 (0.11,1.82) 0.48 (0.12,1.72) ‐0.02 (‐0.11,0.04)
SD ANA + DMARD   0.66 (0.18,2.43) 0.67 (0.19,2.21) ‐0.01 (‐0.09,0.08)
SD CERTO SC + DMARD   0.46 (0.08,2.47) 0.48 (0.08,2.22) ‐0.02 (‐0.12,0.08)
SD TOCI SC + DMARD   0.85 (0.21,3.82) 0.86 (0.22,3.21) 0.00 (‐0.08,0.15)
LD ADA SC   0.44 (0.08,2.38) 0.46 (0.10,2.34) ‐0.03 (‐0.18,0.02)
HD TOFA PO   0.37 (0.06,2.42) 0.38 (0.07,2.38) ‐0.03 (‐0.18,0.02)
HD ADA SC   0.68 (0.14,3.82) 0.70 (0.17,3.67) ‐0.01 (‐0.16,0.04)
HD TOCI IV + DMARD   1.01 (0.32,3.26) 1.01 (0.33,2.86) 0.00 (‐0.06,0.14)
SD ANA + DMARD SD ADA SC + DMARD 1.43 (0.38,5.47) 1.40 (0.40,5.10) 0.01 (‐0.05,0.11)
SD CERTO SC + DMARD   1.00 (0.16,5.64) 1.00 (0.17,5.15) 0.00 (‐0.08,0.11)
SD TOCI SC + DMARD   1.87 (0.43,8.46) 1.81 (0.45,7.40) 0.02 (‐0.04,0.18)
LD ADA SC   0.95 (0.11,9.15) 0.95 (0.12,8.93) 0.00 (‐0.14,0.04)
HD TOFA PO   0.80 (0.08,8.40) 0.80 (0.09,8.19) 0.00 (‐0.15,0.03)
HD ADA SC   1.46 (0.18,14.45) 1.44 (0.21,13.87) 0.01 (‐0.13,0.06)
HD TOCI IV + DMARD   2.18 (0.68,7.44) 2.09 (0.70,6.80) 0.02 (‐0.02,0.16)
SD CERTO SC + DMARD SD ANA + DMARD 0.68 (0.12,3.59) 0.70 (0.13,3.29) ‐0.01 (‐0.11,0.08)
SD TOCI SC + DMARD   1.30 (0.33,5.29) 1.28 (0.35,4.65) 0.01 (‐0.07,0.15)
LD ADA SC   0.68 (0.08,5.77) 0.69 (0.10,5.61) ‐0.01 (‐0.19,0.03)
HD TOFA PO   0.56 (0.05,5.63) 0.57 (0.07,5.47) ‐0.01 (‐0.20,0.03)
HD ADA SC   1.05 (0.13,8.86) 1.05 (0.16,8.49) 0.00 (‐0.17,0.05)
HD TOCI IV + DMARD   1.53 (0.54,4.55) 1.49 (0.56,4.16) 0.01 (‐0.04,0.13)
SD TOCI SC + DMARD SD CERTO SC + DMARD 1.90 (0.33,11.57) 1.83 (0.36,10.40) 0.01 (‐0.07,0.18)
LD ADA SC   0.98 (0.08,12.31) 0.98 (0.10,11.89) 0.00 (‐0.18,0.04)
HD TOFA PO   0.81 (0.07,12.06) 0.81 (0.08,11.72) 0.00 (‐0.19,0.03)
HD ADA SC   1.51 (0.14,18.93) 1.49 (0.17,18.07) 0.01 (‐0.16,0.06)
HD TOCI IV + DMARD   2.21 (0.47,11.44) 2.10 (0.51,10.48) 0.02 (‐0.05,0.17)
LD ADA SC SD TOCI SC + DMARD 0.52 (0.05,4.94) 0.53 (0.07,4.78) ‐0.02 (‐0.26,0.03)
HD TOFA PO   0.43 (0.04,4.68) 0.44 (0.06,4.56) ‐0.02 (‐0.26,0.03)
HD ADA SC   0.81 (0.09,7.72) 0.82 (0.12,7.37) ‐0.01 (‐0.24,0.05)
HD TOCI IV + DMARD   1.17 (0.33,4.05) 1.16 (0.37,3.75) 0.00 (‐0.11,0.12)
HD TOFA PO LD ADA SC 0.82 (0.24,2.89) 0.82 (0.25,2.82) 0.00 (‐0.04,0.03)
HD ADA SC   1.54 (0.64,4.18) 1.52 (0.65,4.01) 0.01 (‐0.01,0.05)
HD TOCI IV + DMARD   2.27 (0.27,18.38) 2.20 (0.28,13.99) 0.03 (‐0.03,0.26)
HD ADA SC HD TOFA PO 1.90 (0.55,6.60) 1.86 (0.56,6.22) 0.02 (‐0.02,0.06)
HD TOCI IV + DMARD   2.71 (0.30,26.42) 2.61 (0.30,19.47) 0.03 (‐0.02,0.27)
HD TOCI IV + DMARD HD ADA SC 1.47 (0.18,10.69) 1.45 (0.19,8.12) 0.01 (‐0.05,0.24)
         
Random‐Effect Model Residual Deviance 54.1 vs 52 data points
  Deviance Information Criteria 294.538
Fixed‐Effect Model Residual Deviance 56.54 vs 52 data points
  Deviance Information Criteria 294.2
Note:        
         
Total Patients 11146      
Total Studies 23      
2‐arm 19      
3‐arm 2      
4‐arm 2