Skip to main content
. 2020 Feb 14;10(5):2367–2376. doi: 10.1002/ece3.6046

Table 1.

Results of: (a) the generalized mixed model on offspring crawling‐out behavior; (b) the linear mixed model on offspring snail size (PC1); and (c) the linear mixed model on offspring shell thickness (PC2) (PC1 and PC2 are the principal components of the principal component analysis on offspring snail mass, shell thickness, and four shell size traits)

Fixed effects Estimate (SE) df Χ2 p
a. Crawling‐out Grand‐parental env. (E1) 0.848 (0.6812) 1 8.29 .0040
Parental env. (E2) −0.090 (0.3864) 1 0.4 .5274
Offspring env. (E3) 1.738 (0.3544) 1 114.46 <.0001
E1 × E2 −0.389 (0.7696) 1 0.01 .9315
E1 × E3 −0.168 (0.7882) 1 1.89 .1687
E2 × E3 −0.146 (0.4242) 1 0.01 .9072
E1 × E2 × E3 0.855 (0.8915) 1 0.91 .3395
Random effects Variance df Χ2 p
Family 0.489 1 14.98 .0001
Individual 0.391 1 8.26 .0040
Fixed effects Estimate (SE) Numdf, Dendf F p
b. Snail size (PC1) Grand‐parental env. (E1) 0.037 (0.8837) 1, 41.93 0.47 .4986
Parental env. (E2) −0.212 (0.4689) 1, 48.96 0.45 .4528
Offspring env. (E3) −0.915 (0.4717) 1, 355.06 17.40 <.0001
E1 × E2 −0.183 (0.9912) 1, 56.62 0.10 .7589
E1 × E3 −0.150 (1.0779) 1, 349.40 0.18 .6695
E2 × E3 0.052 (0.5811) 1, 363.02 0.005 .9463
E1 × E2 × E3 −0.075 (0.2114) 1, 358.88 0.003 .9505
Random effect Variance df Χ2 p
Family 0.3572 1 4.60 .0320
Fixed effects Estimate (SE) Numdf, Dendf F p
c. Shell thickness (PC2) Grand‐parental env. (E1) 0.055 (0.2821) 1, 41.14 0.11 .7409
Parental env. (E2) −0.227 (0.1484) 1, 49.44 0.06 .8066
Offspring env. (E3) 0.313 (0.1543) 1, 356.26 45.04 <.0001
E1 × E2 0.103 (0.3155) 1, 58.24 0.48 .4923
E1 × E3 −0.406 (0.3535) 1, 350.40 4.11 .0433
E2 × E3 0.410 (0.1904) 1, 363.97 6.67 .0102
E1 × E2 × E3 0.099 (0.3975) 1, 359.66 0.06 .8036
Random effect Variance df Χ2 p
Family 0.026 1 1.72 .1892

Bold values indicate significant p‐values (p < .05).