Methods |
Identification of subsequent full‐length publications
|
Data |
|
Comparisons |
Proportion of abstracts published, overall and by meeting
Median time to publication
Oral versus poster presentation
Observational design versus case report versus review versus technical report
North American versus European versus African versus rest of the world origin
Retrospective versus prospective design
Statistical inference stated versus not
Control group included versus not
Subspecialty
|
Outcomes |
49 of 164 abstracts published
17/45 abstracts presented at the 2006 meeting, 23/62 at the 2008 meeting, and 9/57 at the 2010 meeting published
-
Proportion of abstracts published by time
-
Factors related to proportion of abstracts published included
38/118 abstracts presented orally versus 11/46 abstracts presented as poster published
42/135 abstracts describing observational design versus 1/11 abstracts describing case reports versus 3/8 abstracts describing reviews versus 1/6 abstracts describing technical reports versus 2/4 abstracts describing surveys published
3/7 abstracts with origin in North American versus 7/18 with origin in Europe versus 38/133 abstracts with origin in Africa versus 0/5 abstracts with rest of the world origin published
32/96 abstracts describing retrospective design versus 10/39 abstracts describing prospective design published
Statistical inference stated versus not: 57.9% vs. 26.2% (OR 3.8, 95% CI = 1.44 to10.34)
Control group included versus not: 35.3% vs. 24.7% (OR 1.3, 95% CI = 0.46 to 3.79)
|
Notes |
Surgery ‐ pediatrics
Funding not reported
|
Risk of bias |
Item |
Authors' judgement |
Description |
Sampling method? |
Yes |
Included all abstracts. |
Search for publications? |
Yes |
Searched 3 databases. |
Follow‐up time? |
Yes |
The 2010 meeting only had 24 months follow‐up. All other meetings had at least 48 months follow‐up. |
Matching? |
Yes |
Matched by 4 different criteria. |
Adjustment for confounding? |
No |
Examined association of meeting year, type presentation, study design, country of origin, prospective status, presence of statistical inference, presence of a control group, and subspecialty with publication using stratified analysis and Fisher's Exact or Mann‐Whitney U tests. |