Skip to main content
. 2018 Nov 20;2018(11):MR000005. doi: 10.1002/14651858.MR000005.pub4

Nasir 2013.

Methods Identification of subsequent full‐length publications
  • Searched electronic database

    • PubMed, MEDLINE, Google/Google Scholar, and the African Journal OnLine through October 2012

    • Person completing the search not reported

    • Searched by all authors and keywords

    • Matched abstract to full‐length publication by

      • All authors

      • Title

      • Methodology

      • Conclusions

Data
  • Included 164 abstracts presented at the 2006, 2008, and 2010 Pan‐African Pediatric Surgical Association meetings

  • Included all abstracts

Comparisons
  • Proportion of abstracts published, overall and by meeting

  • Median time to publication

  • Oral versus poster presentation

  • Observational design versus case report versus review versus technical report

  • North American versus European versus African versus rest of the world origin

  • Retrospective versus prospective design

  • Statistical inference stated versus not

  • Control group included versus not

  • Subspecialty

Outcomes
  • 49 of 164 abstracts published

  • 17/45 abstracts presented at the 2006 meeting, 23/62 at the 2008 meeting, and 9/57 at the 2010 meeting published

  • Proportion of abstracts published by time

    • Median time to publication = 15 months (IQR = 5 to 26 months)

  • Factors related to proportion of abstracts published included

    • 38/118 abstracts presented orally versus 11/46 abstracts presented as poster published

    • 42/135 abstracts describing observational design versus 1/11 abstracts describing case reports versus 3/8 abstracts describing reviews versus 1/6 abstracts describing technical reports versus 2/4 abstracts describing surveys published

    • 3/7 abstracts with origin in North American versus 7/18 with origin in Europe versus 38/133 abstracts with origin in Africa versus 0/5 abstracts with rest of the world origin published

    • 32/96 abstracts describing retrospective design versus 10/39 abstracts describing prospective design published

    • Statistical inference stated versus not: 57.9% vs. 26.2% (OR 3.8, 95% CI = 1.44 to10.34)

    • Control group included versus not: 35.3% vs. 24.7% (OR 1.3, 95% CI = 0.46 to 3.79)

Notes
  • Surgery ‐ pediatrics

  • Funding not reported

Risk of bias
Item Authors' judgement Description
Sampling method? Yes Included all abstracts.
Search for publications? Yes Searched 3 databases.
Follow‐up time? Yes The 2010 meeting only had 24 months follow‐up. All other meetings had at least 48 months follow‐up.
Matching? Yes Matched by 4 different criteria.
Adjustment for confounding? No Examined association of meeting year, type presentation, study design, country of origin, prospective status, presence of statistical inference, presence of a control group, and subspecialty with publication using stratified analysis and Fisher's Exact or Mann‐Whitney U tests.