Skip to main content
. 2018 Nov 20;2018(11):MR000005. doi: 10.1002/14651858.MR000005.pub4

Whitehouse 2009.

Methods Identification of subsequent full‐length publications
  • Searched electronic database

    • PubMed, Embase, Google/Google Scholar; dates of search not reported

    • Search completed by investigator

    • Searched by first, second, and third author, title, and contents

    • Matched abstract to full‐length publication by

      • Contents

Data
  • Included 1138 abstracts presented at the 2004 and 2005 British Hip Society, 2004 and 2006 European Hip Society, 2004 to 2006 British Orthopedic Association, and 2003 and 2005 European Federation of Orthopaedics and Trauma meetings

  • Included all abstracts accepted for oral presentation related to hip surgery, except Instructional Course Lectures

Comparisons
  • Proportion of abstracts published, overall and by meeting

  • Mean time to publication, overall and by meeting

Outcomes
  • 252 of 1138 abstracts published

  • 17/90 abstracts presented at the 2004 British Hip Society meeting, 15/73 at the 2005 British Hip Society meeting, 27/68 at the 2004 European Hip Society meeting, 30/173 at the 2006 European Hip Society meeting, 8/23 at the 2004 British Orthopedic Association meeting, 5/31 at the 2005 British Orthopedic Association meeting, 8/41 at the 2006 British Orthopedic Association meeting, 57/293 at the 2003 European Federation of Orthopaedics and Trauma meeting, and 85/346 at the 2005 European Federation of Orthopaedics and Trauma meeting published.

  • Proportion of abstracts published by time

    • Mean time to publication = 4.9 months

    • Mean time to publication = 6.9 months for 2004 British Hip Society meeting

    • Mean time to publication = 6.8 months for 2005 British Hip Society meeting

    • Mean time to publication = ‐4.1 months for 2004 European Hip Society meeting

    • Mean time to publication = 0.7 months for 2006 European Hip Society meeting

    • Mean time to publication = 8.3 months for 2004 British Orthopedic Association meeting

    • Mean time to publication = 6.0 months for 2005 British Orthopedic Association meeting

    • Mean time to publication = 2.0 months for 2006 British Orthopedic Association meeting

    • Mean time to publication = 9.5 months for 2003 European Federation of Orthopaedics and Trauma meeting

    • Mean time to publication = 8.3 months for 2005 European Federation of Orthopaedics and Trauma meeting

  • No factors other than meeting and meeting year related to proportion of abstracts published reported

Notes
  • Orthopedics/orthopedic surgery

  • Funding not reported

Risk of bias
Item Authors' judgement Description
Sampling method? Yes Included all abstracts presented orally that described a specific topic with reasonable exceptions, so low risk of bias.
Search for publications? Yes Searched 3 databases.
Follow‐up time? Unclear Date of search not reported.
Matching? No Matched by only 1 criterion.
Adjustment for confounding? No Examined association of meeting and meeting year with publication using stratified analysis and Fisher's Exact test.