Stephens 1980.
Study characteristics | |||
Patient sampling | Retrospective, randomly selected. | ||
Patient characteristics and setting |
N included in study: 555. N in analysis: 120. Age: Mean age 35.4 (range 20‐57). Gender: M 60, F 60. Ethnicity: Not reported. Comorbid disorders: Not reported. Duration of symptoms: Not reported. Concurrent medications used: Phenothiazine alone and treatment with a phenothiazine combined with a tricyclic antidepressant or antianxiety drug. Inclusion criteria: Newly hospitalised patients who had participated in three drug studies between 1964 and 1966. Exclusion criteria: Patients with brain syndromes, major systemic diseases, mental deficiency, and alcoholism or drug abuse. Study aim: Prognostic implications of diagnostic criteria. Previous treatment for schizophrenia: Hospitalisation. Clinical setting: Inpatients. Country: USA. |
||
Index tests |
Description of FRS used: Not reported. Professionals performing test: Not reported. Resolution of discrepancies: Not reported. How FRS used in study: Diagnosis. |
||
Target condition and reference standard(s) |
Reference standard: DSM‐II*. Target condition(s): Schizoprenia (chronic undifferentiated, paranoid, acute undifferentiated), schizoaffective, psychotic depression. Professionals performing test: Not reported. Resolution of discrepancies: Not reported. |
||
Flow and timing |
Study process: 555 newly hospitalised patients admitted over 2 years were participants in previous drug studies. 120 participants were randomly selected. Retrospective diagnoses made by chart review using six sets of criteria including FRS. The seventh diagnosis was made at the time of hospitalisation using DSM‐II. Follow‐up: Mean 9.8 years Exclusion: All included participants in analyses. Followup data that is not relevant for this review was obtained for 82 participants, reasons for exclusions not provided. |
||
Comparative | |||
Notes | *Also reported diagnoses using the New York Research Diagnostic Criteria (RDC), the New Haven Schizophrenia Index (NHSI), the 12‐point “Flexible” criteria system developed by the Washington field center of the International Pilot Study of Schizophrenia (Carpenter et al., 1973) the St. Louis diagnostic criteria (Feighner et al., 1972) and the modification by Bland and Orn (1979) of the St. Louis criteria. | ||
Methodological quality | |||
Item | Authors' judgement | Risk of bias | Applicability concerns |
DOMAIN 1: Patient Selection | |||
Was a consecutive or random sample of patients enrolled? | Unclear | ||
Was a case‐control design avoided? | Yes | ||
Did the study avoid inappropriate exclusions? | Yes | ||
Unclear | Unclear | ||
DOMAIN 2: Index Test All tests | |||
Were the index test results interpreted without knowledge of the results of the reference standard? | Yes | ||
Did the study pre‐specify whether they were using one or multiple FRSs? | No | ||
Unclear | Low | ||
DOMAIN 3: Reference Standard | |||
Is the reference standards likely to correctly classify the target condition? | Unclear | ||
Were the reference standard results interpreted without knowledge of the results of the index tests? | Yes | ||
Unclear | Low | ||
DOMAIN 4: Flow and Timing | |||
Was there an appropriate interval between index test and reference standard? | Unclear | ||
Were all patients included in the analysis? | Yes | ||
Did all patients receive a reference standard? | Yes | ||
Did all patients receive the same reference standard? | Yes | ||
Did all patients receive an index test? | Yes | ||
Did all patients receive the same index test? | Yes | ||
Low |