Skip to main content
. 2009 Apr 15;2009(2):CD001290. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD001290.pub2

Shames 2004.

Methods STUDY DESIGN: Parallel group randomised controlled trial 
 LOCATION, NUMBER OF CENTRES: 3 centres serving low‐income families in San Francisco, USA 
 DURATION OF STUDY: 12 months 
 CONCEALMENT OF ALLOCATION: Unclear 
 DESCRIBED AS RANDOMISED: Yes 
 METHOD OF RANDOMISATION WELL DESCRIBED/APPROPRIATE: 
 DESCRIPTION OF WITHDRAWALS/DROPOUTS: Stated 
 TYPE OF ANALYSIS (AVAILABLE CASE/TREATMENT RECEIVED/ ITT): ITT
No blinding of outcome assessor
Participants N SCREENED: Not reported 
 N RANDOMISED: 119 (intervention: 59; control: 60) 
 N COMPLETED: 97 
 M = 69 
 F = 50 
 MEAN AGE: 8 years 
 BASELINE DETAILS: Hispanic: 57%; African American: 21%; Medicaid: 71.5%; 
 INCLUSION CRITERIA: Moderate‐severe asthma; low‐income family; 5 to 12 years; covered by state health insurance or eligible for state insurance; history of asthma > 6 months; hospitalisation or > 2 ED visits for asthma in previous year 
 EXCLUSION CRITERIA: Children under the care of allergist/pulmonary specialist
Interventions EDUCATION GROUP: Disease management programme including assignment to a case manager who delivered a 3‐session course. Case manager also maintained dialogue over 32 weeks of study. Participants also given computer game aimed to improve asthma; 2 visits to specialist; telephone advice line staffed 18 hours/day by specialists.
Setting: Home
CONTROL GROUP: Usual care and non‐violent computer game
TREATMENT PERIOD: 32 weeks (duration of availability of case manager) 
 FOLLOW‐UP PERIOD: 12 months
Outcomes ED visits; symptoms; lung function; quality of life; knowledge scores
Notes  
Risk of bias
Bias Authors' judgement Support for judgement
Adequate sequence generation? Unclear risk Block randomisation to generate balance between younger and older children
Allocation concealment? Unclear risk Information not available
Incomplete outcome data addressed? 
 All outcomes Unclear risk Described as intention‐to‐treat; no explicit description of how this population was composed