Table 4.
Quality of PBM and evidence | |||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Construct validity | Test-retest reliability | Responsiveness | |||||||
China | ± | H | [28, 42, 82, 87, 89, 90] | ||||||
Hong Kong | + | H | [17, 18, 78, 80] | + | La | [79] | ± | La | [81] |
Japan | – | H | [66] | ||||||
Singapore | + | H | [12, 40, 84, 86] | ± | Va.b | [12] | ± | La | [12, 24] |
South Korea | + | H | [33] | ||||||
Thailand | ± | H | [61] | ||||||
Cancer | + | H | [73] | ± | La | [81] | |||
Eye disease | + | La | [24] | ||||||
General population | ± | H | [28, 66, 80, 89] | ||||||
Genitourinary disease | ± | H | [90] | ||||||
Heart disease | ± | H | [82] | ||||||
Hepatitis | ± | H | [78] | ||||||
Kidney disease | + | H | [86] | ||||||
Mental disorders | + | H | [12] | ± | Va,b | [12] | ± | La | [12] |
Multiple conditions | ± | H | [61] | ||||||
Musculoskeletal disease | + | H | [18, 87] | ||||||
Respiratory disease | + | H | [17] | ||||||
Rheumatic disease | + | H | [40, 84] | ||||||
Stroke | + | H | [33] | ||||||
Thyroid disease | + | La | [79] |
Quality of PBM: + indicates sufficient results; ± indicates inconsistent results; – indicates insufficient results
Italicised font indicates that grading is based on no more than three studies
SF-6D Short Form-6 Dimensions, PBM preference-based measure, ROB risk of bias
Quality of evidence: H indicates high; L indicates low; V indicates very low
aQuality downgraded by 2 levels due to ROB
bQuality downgraded by 1 level due to imprecision