Skip to main content
. 2020 Feb 21;21(2):235–243. doi: 10.5811/westjem.2019.10.40892

Table 1.

Characteristics of EMTALA-related civil monetary penalty settlements involving obstetrical emergencies.

Obstetrical Non-obstetrical P-value Test type
Total number 39 193
Settlement (mean US dollars) $36,269.23 $43,677.87 0.6386 Student’s t-test
n % n %
Settlement against physican 3 8% 5 3% 0.134 Fischer's exact test
Minor involved 7 18% 24 12% 0.356 Pearson Chi squared
Failure to MSE 32 82% 142 74% 0.265 Pearson Chi squared
Failure to stabilize 20 51% 105 54% 0.721 Pearson Chi squared
Failure to arrange transfer 14 36% 40 21% 0.041 Pearson Chi squared
Failure to accept transfer 2 5% 29 15% 0.123 Fischer's exact test
On call failed to respond 1 3% 13 7% 0.475 Fischer's exact test
CMS region 0.052 Fischer’s exact test
 1 2 5% 5 3%
 2 0 0% 8 4%
 3 3 8% 1 1%
 4 15 38% 81 42%
 5 4 10% 20 10%
 6 8 21% 20 10%
 7 2 5% 25 13%
 8 0 0% 6 3%
 9 5 13% 27 14%
 10 0 0% 0 0%

EMTALA, Emergency Medical Treatment and Labor Act; OIG, Office of the Inspector General; MSE, medical screening exam; CMS, Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services.