Skip to main content
. 2020 Mar 20;15(3):e0230313. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0230313

Table 1. Breast cancer patient cohorts used for biomarker discovery and validation.

Throughout this document we will use the definition of HR negative as ER negative and PR negative. While HR positive is defined as not HR negative, i.e. ER positive and PR positive, ER positive and PR negative, ER negative and PR positive.

Discovery Validation
Data Hatzis et al. Hatzis et al. Horak et al. MAQC consortium
Name alias - hatzis182 horak121 maqc264
Source E-GEOD-25055 E-GEOD-25065 E-GEOD-41998 E-GEOD-20194
Platform HG-U133A HG-U133A HG-U133A_2 HG-U133A
N(1) 306 182 121 264
HR status
positive 184 121 55 -
negative 117 60 66 -
ER status
positive 172 113 45 161
negative 129 68 76 103
PR status
positive 140 94 46 -
negative 160 87 75 -
HER2 status(2)
positive 3 0 9 56
negative 288 182 112 208
Response
pCR 57 42 34 55
RD 249 140 87 209
Response Rate 19% 23% 28% 20%
Chemotherapy regime(3)
neoadjuvant 306 165 121 264
partial adjuvant 0 18 0 0
adjuvant 0 15 0 0
Taxane(4)
Paclitaxel 287 92 121 264
Docetaxel 18 90 0 0
Combination
FAC (5) 227 103 0 182
AC (6) 83 0 121 0
FEC (7) 0 125 0 78
X (8) 0 94 0 0
Trastuzumab 0 0 0 8
Other 0 0 0 5

(1) Patients with reported response status were considered

(2) Samples of the Hatzis et al. study are assumed HER2- where no explicit meta information has been found

(3) Chemotherapy regime was not reported for individual patients by Hatzis et al.

(4) Taxane was not specified for one patient in Discovery

(5) Fluorouracil (F), doxorubicin (A) and cyclophosphamide (C).

(6) Doxorubicin (A) and cyclophosphamide (C).

(7) Fluorouracil (F), epirubicin (E) and cyclophosphamide(C).

(8) Capecitabine.