Table 6.
Type of Model | Name | Skill | Provider | Validity |
---|---|---|---|---|
Virtual Reality | dVSS | Basic skills | Intuitive Surgical, USA | Face, content, construct, concurrent and predictive99–101 |
dV-Trainer | Basic skills | Mimic Technologies, USA | Face, content, construct, concurrent and predictive99–102 | |
FlexVR | Basic skills | Mimic Technologies, USA | None | |
RobotiX Mentor | Basic skills | 3D Systems formerly Simbionix | Face, content and construct100,101,103 | |
RARP | Face, content and construct104 | |||
RoSS | Basic skills | Simulated Surgical Systems, USA | Face, content and construct100,101 | |
Urethrovesical anastomosis AR* | Concurrent105 | |||
RARP | None | |||
RARC | None | |||
Lymph node dissection | None | |||
Tube-3 | Urethrovesical anastomosis | Mimic Technologies, USA | Face, content, construct, concurrent and predictive106–108 | |
Maestro AR* | RAPN | Mimic Technologies, USA | Face, content, construct and concurrent109 | |
RARP | None | |||
Xperience Team Trainer | Assistant skills | Mimic Technologies, USA | Face, content, construct and concurrent110 | |
Bench | Mimic dry-lab exercises | Basic skills | Mimic Technologies, USA | Face, content and construct111 |
SIMPLE-PN | RAPN | University of Rochester, USA | Face, content, construct and concurrent112,113 | |
RAPN Training | RAPN | Washington University, St Louis USA | Face, content and construct114 | |
Urethrovesical model | Urethrovesical anastomosis | University of Texas, Dallas USA | Face, content and construct115 | |
Urethrovesical model | Urethrovesical anastomosis | Geisel School of Medicine at Dartmouth | Face and content116 | |
Animal | Porcine kidney with an embedded Styrofoam ball | RAPN | – | Face, content and construct117 |
Porcine bowel | Intracorporeal bowel anastomosis | – | Face, content and construct118 | |
Chicken model | Urethrovesical anastomosis | – | Face and content119 | |
Porcine genitourinary tract | RARP | – | Face, content and construct120 | |
Cadaveric | Fresh frozen cadavers | Basic skills | – | Face and content121 |
RARP | – | Face122 |
Abbreviations: dVSS, da Vinci Skills Simulator; RARP, robotic-assisted radical prostatectomy; RoSS, Robotic Surgery Simulator; AR*, augmented reality; RARC, robotic-assisted radical cystectomy; RAPN, robotic-assisted partial nephrectomy.