Indirect analysis (derivative method)
|
IEC
|
Post-column ninhydrin-derived IEC can simultaneously detect primary and secondary amino acids, and is suitable for the analysis and detection of amino acids in complex samples. |
The conditions for the derivatization reaction are demanding, and a heating derivative device is required; the analysis process is long, the detection cost is high, and it will cause serious glycine contamination. |
No in situ detection |
UV–VIS
|
In visible light detection, the sensitivity of the ninhydrin-derived and DABSYL-Cl color reaction is high, the stability of the derivative is good, and the latter is simpler and more efficient [49]. In UV detection, the OPA derivatization agent itself does not interfere with separation and detection, the derivatization operation is simple, and the sensitivity and repeatability are good [50]. |
Although there are many types of derivatizing agents, none of the derivatizing agents are fully suitable for the analysis of all amino acids [51]. It is necessary to select different derivatizing agents for the types of amino acids to be tested; only the total amount of one or a class of amino acids can be determined, and the separation and analysis of amino acids cannot be performed [52]. |
GC
|
High performance, good selectivity, high sensitivity, and simple operation. |
Derivative conditions are harsh: unstable and non-volatile materials cannot be separated, and because of the characteristics of different amino acids (such as the rate of derivatization or the different derivatization reagents), the determination of all of the amino acids cannot be performed using the same column. In addition, the sample needs to be desalted, and the operation of the experiment is cumbersome and can cause pollution [53]. |
GC–MS
|
More efficient than GC. |
RP-HPLC
|
Pre-column derivation overcomes the disadvantages of post-column derivation operations, and has a high sensitivity, fast analysis, and diverse reagents. |
Different derivatizing reagents have their own shortcomings [32], and often problems such as unstable derivatives, cumbersome reaction conditions, and long operating times are not conducive to the rapid analysis of amino acids [30]. The derivative process cannot be replaced by an instrument, it must be done manually, and the cost of detection is high [54]. |
CE
|
High separation efficiency, faster analysis, no gradient elution, wide range of applications, small sample size, simple instrument, and low cost [55]. |
Still need to use chemical derivation technology, is time-consuming and laborious, and has a reduced accuracy. |
LC–MS
|
High sensitivity and selectivity, able to provide sufficient sample structure information, no complicated pre-processing or derivatization of the sample, high detection efficiency, and good anti-interference performance. |
Instruments are expensive and costly to test. |
Direct analysis
|
LC–ELSD
|
The response of ELSD does not depend on the optical properties of the sample. It can directly detect the properties of the material without UV absorption or fluorescence functional groups, and is not affected by its functional groups. Any sample with a lower volatility than the mobile phase can be detected [52], no derivative is required, there are a wide range of applications, and it is suitable for the rapid determination of amino acids. |
Low detection sensitivity, high detection limit, and cannot solve the problem of detection of trace amino acids well. |
IPAD
|
No cumbersome sample preparation steps, you can directly measure the sample by diluting it to the appropriate concentration, and it has a high accuracy and sensitivity. |
High requirements for experimental operations (instruments and experimenters) [56]. |
LIF
|
Each substance has a corresponding “fingerprint” fluorescence spectrum. A wide range of detectability, a low detection limit, no complicated derivative process, no damage to the sample, it is portable and efficient, has an ultra-high sensitivity [57], and has in situ monitoring. |
In situ detection technology is still immature, it has fluorescence absorption and quenching, the detection accuracy is limited by the instrument signal-to-noise ratio, etc. |
In situ detection |