Skip to main content
. 2020 Mar 6;20(5):1461. doi: 10.3390/s20051461

Table 1.

The heartbeat detection performance comparison using the MIT-BIH data set.

Method Year Total Heartbeats TP FP FN SEN +P DER ACC
Pan–Tompkins [56] 1985 116,137 115,860 507 277 99.76% 99.56% 0.68% 99.33%
FBBBD [57] 1999 91,283 90,909 406 374 99.59% 99.56% 0.86% 99.15%
S.W.Chen [58] 2006 102,654 102,195 529 459 99.55% 99.49% 0.97% 99.04%
DOM [60] 2008 116,137 115,971 58 166 99.86% 99.95% 0.19% 99.81%
S.Choi [59] 2010 109,494 109,118 218 376 99.66% 99.80% 0.54% 99.46%
Z.Zidelmal [61] 2012 109,494 109,101 193 393 99.64% 99.82% 0.54% 99.47%
SEEHT [63] 2012 109,496 109,417 140 79 99.93% 99.87% 0.2% 99.80%
S.Banerjee [68] 2012 19140 19126 20 20 99.90% 99.90% 0.21% 99.79%
PSEE [64] 2013 109,494 109,401 91 93 99.92% 99.92% 0.17% 99.83%
F.Bouaziz [62] 2014 109,494 109,354 232 140 99.87% 99.79% 0.34% 99.66%
A.Karimipour [69] 2014 116,137 115,945 308 192 99.83% 99.74% 0.43% 99.57%
ISEE [65] 2016 109,532 109,474 116 58 99.95% 99.89% 0.16% 99.84%
WTSEE [66] 2017 109,494 109,415 99 79 99.93% 99.91% 0.16% 99.84%