Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2020 Dec 1.
Published in final edited form as: Magn Reson Imaging. 2019 Jun 24;64:132–141. doi: 10.1016/j.mri.2019.05.038

Table 1:

Evaluation of brain ventricle parcellation on 70 NPH subjects. We performed paired two-tail Wilcoxon signed-rank tests between interpolation, JogSSR, and SMORE.

Metrics Thickness Interp. JogSSR SMORE HR(0.9 mm)
SSIM 1.205 mm 0.9494 0.9507 0.9726* 1*
1.928 mm 0.9013 0.9106 0.9389*
3.0125 mm 0.8290 0.8400 0.8893*
3.856 mm 0.7677 0.7812 0.8387*
4.82 mm 0.7003 0.7170 0.7817*

PSNR 1.205 mm 35.0407 34.0472 39.5053*
1.928 mm 31.9321 30.6444 35.7429*
3.0125 mm 29.2785 27.4384 31.9878*
3.856 mm 27.7562 25.7118 29.6050*
4.82 mm 26.4127 24.2377 28.1593*

Dice(RLV) 1.205 mm 0.9704 0.9705 0.9712 0.9715*
1.928 mm 0.9678 0.9690 0.9706*
3.0125 mm 0.9610 0.9635 0.9693*
3.856 mm 0.9527 0.9578 0.9648*
4.82 mm 0.9405 0.9498 0.9629*

Dice(LLV) 1.205 mm 0.9710 0.9709 0.9715 0.9717
1.928 mm 0.9690 0.9693 0.9710*
3.0125 mm 0.9638 0.9641 0.9699*
3.856 mm 0.9571 0.9585 0.9663*
4.82 mm 0.9469 0.9510 0.9638*

Dice(3rd) 1.205 mm 0.9149 0.9149 0.9163 0.9174*
1.928 mm 0.9095 0.9097 0.9141*
3.0125 mm 0.8945 0.8940 0.9073*
3.856 mm 0.8779 0.8761 0.8937*
4.82 mm 0.8560 0.8545 0.8832*

Dice(4th) 1.205 mm 0.8954 0.8941 0.8973* 0.8983*
1.928 mm 0.8891 0.8851 0.8947*
3.0125 mm 0.8741 0.8657 0.8878*
3.856 mm 0.8550 0.8463 0.8753*
4.82 mm 0.8254 0.8216 0.8629*

Dice(whole) 1.205 mm 0.9690 0.9690 0.9696 0.9699*
1.928 mm 0.9665 0.9672 0.9690*
3.0125 mm 0.9602 0.9614 0.9675*
3.856 mm 0.9524 0.9552 0.9632*
4.82 mm 0.9408 0.9470 0.9607*

The ‘*’ (p < 0.005) and ‘†’ (p < 0.05) indicate the method is significantly better than the other two methods. For the column of ‘HR’, they indicate that HR images give significantly better parcellation results than resolved images from the three methods with thickness of 1.205 mm.