Skip to main content
. 2020 Mar 25;15(3):e0230669. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0230669

Table 4. Group-level validation tests comparing energy-adjusted food intakes estimated by the food frequency questionnaire and the 24-hour recall at each time-point.

Food items Age 1.5 years (n = 231) Age 3.5 years (n = 172) Age 5.0 yearsT3(n = 187)
Bland-Altman Spearman rs P-value Bland-Altman LOA index Bland-Altman Spearman rs P-value Bland-Altman LOA index Bland-Altman Spearman rs P-value Bland-Altman LOA index
Water 0.20 4.8% 0.04 3.5% 0.02 2.1%
Milk <0.001 5.2% 0.03 5.8% 0.002 3.7%
All other beverages 0.01 3.0% <0.001 7.0% 0.01 4.3%
Cheese 0.52 6.0% <0.001 6.4% <0.001 4.8%
Yoghurt 0.34 6.1% 0.31 6.4% 0.001 4.3%
Cream/ ice-cream/custards 0.01 6.1% 0.55 2.9% 0.06 4.3%
Non-white bread 0.44 7.8% <0.001 6.4% <0.001 5.3%
White bread 0.09 6.9% 0.02 7.6% 0.75 7.5%
Breakfast cereal <0.001 6.0% <0.001 7.6% <0.001 5.9%
Rice/pasta/other cereals 0.001 3.9% 0.001 4.7% 0.004 5.3%
Red meat 0.53 5.6% 0.90 5.8% 0.65 5.3%
Poultry 0.04 6.9% 0.25 5.8% <0.001 4.8%
Seafood 0.11 6.5% 0.047 6.4% 0.06 6.4%
Processed meat <0.001 5.2% <0.001 5.2% 0.015 5.3%
Eggs 0.02 6.5% 0.003 1.1% 0.004 6.4%
Fruit 0.002 5.2% 0.09 7.6% <0.001 4.3%
Vegetables (no potatoes) 0.19 6.5% 0.24 5.8% 0.103 7.0%
Potato 0.01 5.2% 0.02 4.7% 0.001 5.3%
Hot chips 0.004 5.2% 0.09 4.7% 0.27 9.1%
Takeaway style foods 0.61 5.2% 0.02 8.1% 0.08 4.3%
Sweet snack foods <0.001 4.3% <0.001 5.2% <0.001 4.3%
Savoury snack foods <0.001 5.2% 0.09 4.7% <0.001 4.3%
Crispbreads and crackers <0.001 6.1% 0.65 4.1% 0.003 7.0%
Nuts and seeds <0.001 3.9% 0.58 5.2% 0.45 7.5%
Butter and margarine <0.001 4.8% 0.01 5.2% 0.052 5.9%
Sugars, jams and honey 0.01 4.3% <0.001 4.7% <0.001 4.3%

†Bland-Altman Spearman’s correlation r P-value ≤0.05 (presence of proportional bias), Bland-Altman Limits of Agreement (LOA) index (<5% being acceptable)