Skip to main content
. 2009 Jan 21;2009(1):CD001199. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD001199.pub2
Disease‐free survival
Study Survival % year 1 Survival % year 2 Survival % year 3 Survival % year 4 Survival % year 5 Median survival Survival p‐value
Izumi 1994 Surgery: 43% 
 Adjuvant: 65% Surgery: 22% 
 Adjuvant: 55% Surgery: 12% 
 Adjuvant: 32% Surgery: 6% 
 Adjuvant: 25% Surgery: 0% 
 Adjuvant: 6% Surgery: 1.3 years 
 Adjuvant: 2.3 years p = 0.0237 
 (Adjuvant: doxorubicin + mitomycin +/‐ transarterial embolization)
Lai 1998 Surgery: 69% 
 Adjuvant: 50% Surgery: 53% 
 Adjuvant: 36% Surgery: 48% 
 Adjuvant: 18% Surgery: 48% 
 Adjuvant: 6% Not given Surgery: 2.5 years 
 Adjuvant: 1.0 year p = 0.04 
 (Adjuvant: epirubicin+cisplatin)
Lau 1999 Surgery: 60% 
 Adjuvant: 86% Surgery: 38% 
 Adjuvant: 75% Surgery: 38% 
 Adjuvant: 75% Surgery: 38% 
 Adjuvant: 75% Surgery: 38% 
 Adjuvant: 50% Surgery: 1.8 years 
 Adjuvant: not reached p=0.037 
 (Adjuvant: lipiodol‐iodine‐131)
Nishiguchi 2005 Surgery: 72% 
 Adjuvant: 92% Surgery: 60% 
 Adjuvant: 67% Surgery: 20% 
 Adjuvant: 67% Surgery: 20% 
 Adjuvant: 67% Surgery: 20% 
 Adjuvant: 67% Surgery: 2.6 years 
 Adjuvant: not reached p=0.055 
 (adjuvant: interferon‐alpha)
Ono 1997 Surgery: 89% 
 Adjuvant: 68% Surgery: 70% 
 Adjuvant: 45% Surgery: 42% 
 Adjuvant: 32% Surgery: 28% 
 Adjuvant: 32% Surgery: 0% 
 Adjuvant: 32% Surgery: 2.5 years 
 Adjuvant: 2.0 years p = 0.07302 
 (Adjuvant: epirubicin+oral HCFU)
Takayama 2000 Surgery: 65% 
 Adjuvant: 85% Surgery: 48% 
 Adjuvant: 70% Surgery: 33% 
 Adjuvant: 48% Surgery: 28% 
 Adjuvant: 42% Surgery: 22% 
 Adjuvant: 40% Surgery: 2.0 years 
 Adjuvant: 3.0 years p=0.008 
 (Adjuvant: immunotherapy)
Wu 1995 Surgery: 70% 
 Adjuvant: 65% Surgery: 55% 
 Adjuvant: 45% Surgery: 50% 
 Adjuvant: 40% Surgery: 50% 
 Adjuvant: 32% Surgery: 45% 
 Adjuvant: 20% Surgery: 3.0 years 
 Adjuvant: 1.5 years p = 0.27 
 (Neoadjuvant: doxorubicin+TACE)
Yamamoto 1996 Stage I: Surgery: 80% 
 Stage I: Adjuvant: 90% 
 
 Stage II: Surgery: 75% 
 Stage II: Adjuvant: 70% Stage I: Surgery: 60% 
 Stage I: Adjuvant: 70% 
 
 Stage II: Surgery: ‐ 
 Stage II: Adjuvant: 30% Stage I: Surgery: 30% 
 Stage I: Adjuvant: 70% 
 
 Stage II: Surgery: ‐ 
 Stage II: Adjuvant: 15% Stage I: Surgery: 30% 
 Adjuvant: 50% 
 Stage II: Not given Stage I: Surgery: 19% 
 Adjuvant: 50% 
 Stage II: Not given Stage I: Surgery: 2.0 years 
 Stage I: Adjuvant: 5.5 years 
 
 Stage II: Surgery: 1.5 years 
 Stage II: Adjuvant: 1.5 years STAGE I: p = 0.04 
 STAGE II: p = 1.00 
 (Adjuvant: oral 1‐hexylcarbamoyl 5‐fluorouracil (HCFU))
Yamasaki 1996 Surgery: 85% 
 Adjuvant: 85% Surgery: 60% 
 Adjuvant: 65% Surgery: 40% 
 Adjuvant: 55% Surgery: 35% 
 Adjuvant: 48% Surgery: 30% 
 Adjuvant: 40% Surgery: 2.0 years 
 Adjuvant: 3.0 years Not significant 
 (Neoadjuvant: doxorubicin+TACE)