Skip to main content
. 2017 Mar 21;375(2):38. doi: 10.1007/s41061-017-0127-6

Table 1.

Advantages and disadvantages of the different RNAi-based silencing systems

RNAi molecule Activity Advantage Disadvantage

MicroRNAs

[32]

Naturally occurring small RNA molecule responsible for regulation of mRNA translation

Naturally occurring, some are known to be involved in cancer and virus regulation [4345]

Active in the cytoplasm

Enters RISC directly

Highly unstable in physiological conditions

May have multiple mRNA targets, resulting in off-target side effects

Synthetic small interfering RNA (siRNA)

[27]

Synthetic double-stranded RNA molecule with complementary sequence to target gene

Specifically designed to target the gene of interest, minimising off-target effects

Highly effective in laboratory environments

Active in the cytoplasm

Enters RISC directly

Highly unstable in physiological conditions

May activate an immune response

Short hairpin RNA (shRNA)

[21]

Artificial RNA molecule with an artificially designed tight hairpin loop. One stem sequence is complementary to the target gene

Can be delivered as a plasmid or virus vector with a poll III promoter for more stable and longer-lasting treatment

Enters the RNAi pathway at an earlier step than siRNA, which may be advantageous for activity

Needs to be delivered to the nucleus, requiring crossing of the nuclear membrane

May activate an immune response

May result in excess RNAi molecule expression, leading to saturation of the natural miRNA pathways and resulting in severe toxicities [46]

Mirised short hairpin RNA (shRNAmir)

[39, 40]

Artificial RNA molecule with a hairpin loop and bulges derived from a native microRNA. One stem sequence is complementary to the target gene

More stable as delivered via a plasmid or virus vector

Mimics the native miRNAs more closely, therefore recognised by the RNAi machinery more accurately

Enters the RNAi pathway at an earlier step than siRNA

Needs to be delivered to the nucleus, requiring crossing of the nuclear membrane

May activate an immune response

May result in excess RNAi molecule expression, leading to saturation of the natural miRNA pathways and resulting in severe toxicities [46]

Artificial MicroRNA cluster

[42]

Artificial RNA molecule with multiple stem loops derived from a native microRNA cluster, i.e. mir-17-92, stem sequences have been replaced to be complementary to the target gene/s

As above, with the additional benefit of delivering multiple

RNAi molecules for targeting of several sites of one gene or different genes

Avoidance of escape mutants

As above

First RNAi molecule is expressed at higher levels than remaining molecules [47]