Table 4.
Comparison of laparoscopic versus open abdominal procedures in cirrhotic patients
| Study | Design | Population | Findings |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cholecystectomy | |||
| Chimielecki et al27 | Retrospective cohort |
Open: 1852 Lap: 13,809 |
Open procedures associated with higher postop infection, hemorrhage, pRBC transfusion, liver failure |
| Laurence et al25 | Meta-analysis of 3 RCTs35–37 |
Open: 108 Lap: 112 |
Open procedures associated with increased total postop complications, infections, hepatic insufficiency, and hospital LOS |
| Colectomy | |||
| Martinez et al38 | Retrospective | Lap: 17 | Morbidity 29% compared to 30–48% morbidity in open colon resections12,39 |
| Appendectomy | |||
| Tsugawa et al40 | Retrospective |
Open: 40 Lap: 15 |
Open procedures associated with increased postoperative morbidity and pain |