Skip to main content
. 2020 Mar 24;22:55–68. doi: 10.1016/j.ctro.2020.03.009

Table 2.

Radiotherapy Treatments that may be omitted.

Disease Site Subsite or classification Modality Comments and Evidence
Breast
Breast Conservation
DCIS Omission of radiotherapy to whole breast [27] No survival benefit, small benefit in loco-regional recurrence
Invasive disease
Low risk, older patients
Omission of radiotherapy to whole breast [29], [47] Endocrine therapy only sufficient in > 70 (>65in PRIMEII)
[29]
Invasive disease
Genomic profile low risk
Omission of radiotherapy to whole breast LUMINA, IDEA, PRECISION, PRIMETIME trials ongoing (caution outside of trial)
Age ≥ 50, ER+, Her2- breast ca without other adverse pathologic features Omission of boost radiotherapy [26], [48] No survival benefit
Post Mastectomy
T1-2 N1 (Node + Breast Cancer) Omit radiotherapy NSABP B-51/RTOG 1304 trials ongoing
CNS
Glioblastoma
Age > 60, methylated
Temozolamide only [49], [50] Standard radiotherapy associated with poor outcomes
Low grade glioma Omit radiotherapy
Asymptomatic meningioma Gr 1–2 Omit radiotherapy
Asymptomatic AVM Omit radiotherapy
Esophagus
Resection or chemoradiation rather than trimodality therapy
Gastric
Resectable Treat with chemotherapy only
Unresectable Treat with chemotherapy only [51]
Lung
SCLC, Extensive Omit prophylactic cranial irradiation [52] Also consider omission of consolidation thoracic radiotherapy in extensive stage disease
Pancreas
Unresectable Omit radiotherapy [53] Consider chemotherapy or clinical trial
Prostate
Low, favorable intermediate risk Active surveillance [54]
Benign Disease
Keloid, Heterotopic Ossification, Actinic Keratosis Omit radiotherapy Not life-threatening, topicals (NSAIDS) may be reasonable alternatives (vs. delay in the far future)
Palliative
Painful mets, uncomplicated, other systemic options Ensure medical optimization (e.g. WHO Pain Ladder)
Oligometastatic (e.g. Prostate Cancer) Omit radiotherapy Systemic treatment e.g. androgen deprivation therapy
Postoperative radiotherapy (for pathologic fracture) [55] Omit radiotherapy Limited/evidence of benefit
CNS mets from NSCLC needing WBRT [19] Omit radiotherapy Best supportive care including steroids
Testicular
Seminoma, stage I Omit radiotherapy Consider observation or carboplatin

These therapies have (mainly) been established by randomised controlled evidence and have are frequently considered a standard of care. In the context of a pandemic the risk benefit of these treatments is altered. General criteria for omission may include more time-sensitive need for treatment decision-making (go vs. no go) and availability of non-emergency/urgency, lower-risk alternatives, etc. that make the additional risk of treating the patient during the pandemic greater than the risk of omitting radiation taking alternatives into account.