Table 2.
Radiotherapy Treatments that may be omitted.
| Disease Site | Subsite or classification | Modality | Comments and Evidence |
|---|---|---|---|
| Breast | |||
| Breast Conservation | |||
| DCIS | Omission of radiotherapy to whole breast [27] | No survival benefit, small benefit in loco-regional recurrence | |
| Invasive disease Low risk, older patients |
Omission of radiotherapy to whole breast [29], [47] | Endocrine therapy only sufficient in > 70 (>65in PRIMEII) [29] |
|
| Invasive disease Genomic profile low risk |
Omission of radiotherapy to whole breast | LUMINA, IDEA, PRECISION, PRIMETIME trials ongoing (caution outside of trial) | |
| Age ≥ 50, ER+, Her2- breast ca without other adverse pathologic features | Omission of boost radiotherapy [26], [48] | No survival benefit | |
| Post Mastectomy | |||
| T1-2 N1 (Node + Breast Cancer) | Omit radiotherapy | NSABP B-51/RTOG 1304 trials ongoing | |
| CNS | |||
| Glioblastoma Age > 60, methylated |
Temozolamide only [49], [50] | Standard radiotherapy associated with poor outcomes | |
| Low grade glioma | Omit radiotherapy | ||
| Asymptomatic meningioma Gr 1–2 | Omit radiotherapy | ||
| Asymptomatic AVM | Omit radiotherapy | ||
| Esophagus | |||
| Resection or chemoradiation rather than trimodality therapy | |||
| Gastric | |||
| Resectable | Treat with chemotherapy only | ||
| Unresectable | Treat with chemotherapy only [51] | ||
| Lung | |||
| SCLC, Extensive | Omit prophylactic cranial irradiation [52] | Also consider omission of consolidation thoracic radiotherapy in extensive stage disease | |
| Pancreas | |||
| Unresectable | Omit radiotherapy [53] | Consider chemotherapy or clinical trial | |
| Prostate | |||
| Low, favorable intermediate risk | Active surveillance [54] | ||
| Benign Disease | |||
| Keloid, Heterotopic Ossification, Actinic Keratosis | Omit radiotherapy | Not life-threatening, topicals (NSAIDS) may be reasonable alternatives (vs. delay in the far future) | |
| Palliative | |||
| Painful mets, uncomplicated, other systemic options | Ensure medical optimization (e.g. WHO Pain Ladder) | ||
| Oligometastatic (e.g. Prostate Cancer) | Omit radiotherapy | Systemic treatment e.g. androgen deprivation therapy | |
| Postoperative radiotherapy (for pathologic fracture) [55] | Omit radiotherapy | Limited/evidence of benefit | |
| CNS mets from NSCLC needing WBRT [19] | Omit radiotherapy | Best supportive care including steroids | |
| Testicular | |||
| Seminoma, stage I | Omit radiotherapy | Consider observation or carboplatin |
These therapies have (mainly) been established by randomised controlled evidence and have are frequently considered a standard of care. In the context of a pandemic the risk benefit of these treatments is altered. General criteria for omission may include more time-sensitive need for treatment decision-making (go vs. no go) and availability of non-emergency/urgency, lower-risk alternatives, etc. that make the additional risk of treating the patient during the pandemic greater than the risk of omitting radiation taking alternatives into account.