Table 2.
Illustrative summary of non-pharmaceutical, non-vaccine, public health measures to counter widespread emerging respiratory virus threats
Category | Specific intervention | Evidence base and consequences |
---|---|---|
International travel measures | Travel advice | • Minimal evidence |
Entry screening | • Minimal evidence — moderately disruptive | |
Border closures | • Minimally effective unless 100% complete • Unsustainable until vaccine is available • Very disruptive to society |
|
Personal protective measures | Regular hand washing | • Effective to some extent |
Good respiratory hygiene | • Uncertain (presumed effective) | |
General mask-wearing outside the home | • Uncertain | |
Mask-wearing in high-risk situations | • Uncertain • Possibly partially effective in healthcare settings |
|
Mask-wearing by people with respiratory infection | • Effective to some extent | |
Early self-isolation | • Uncertain but presumed effective | |
Quarantine measures | • Ineffective for influenza; more effective for SARS-CoV | |
Social distancing measures | Internal travel restrictions | • Possibly minor delaying effect • Disruptive |
Reactive school closures | • Effective to some extent • Potentially disruptive secondary effects • Difficult to gauge when to re-open |
|
Proactive school closures | • Effective to some extent • Very substantial secondary effects • Difficult to gauge when to re-open |
|
Reactive workplace closures | • Uncertain | |
Home working and reducing meetings | • Uncertain | |
Cancellation of public gatherings | • Uncertain • Potentially disruptive |
Adapted with permission from [26••].