Skip to main content
. 2020 Mar 23;10(3):e034568. doi: 10.1136/bmjopen-2019-034568

Table 1.

Item list used to extract eligible papers

Item groups Item list Detailed items
General characteristics Diagnostic task What is the target condition?
Study objective Is the study aiming at the development of a diagnostic method, evaluation of a diagnostic method or both?
Target population What is the population targeted by the diagnostic test?
Methods Data sources Where and when potentially eligible participants were identified (setting, location and dates)
Data split Method for partitioning the evaluation set from the training data. To assess whether participants formed a consecutive, random or convenience series.
Test dataset eligibility criteria On what basis potentially eligible participants were identified within the test dataset (such as symptoms, results from previous tests, inclusion in registry).
Results Baseline characteristics Baseline demographic and clinical characteristics of participants
Diagnosis/non-diagnosis classification Classification of the diagnosed and non-diagnosed patients within the test set.
Flow diagram Flow of participants, using a diagram.
Severity Distribution of severity of disease in those with the target condition.
Alternative diagnosis Distribution of alternative diagnoses in those without the target condition.
Difference between reference test and ML test Is there a time interval between index test and reference standard?
Applicability Does the evaluation population correspond to the setting in which the diagnosis test will be applied?

ML, machine learning.