Skip to main content
. 2018 Aug 31;80:31–47. doi: 10.1016/j.actbio.2018.08.033

Table 1.

Generalized qualitative comparisons of vaccine classifications. Please note that a few exceptions may contradict the generalized qualitative comparisons. Details on administration routes, advantages and disadvantages regarding production, immunogenicity, biosafety, transportation/storage, and examples of commercialized DNA- and amino acid-based vaccines for each vaccine classification are tabulated. The ‘+’ and ‘−’ denote general pros and cons.

Live attenuated vaccines Killed or Inactivated vaccines Inactivated toxoid vaccines Polysaccharide vaccines Conjugate polysaccharide vaccines Recombinant protein vaccines DNA vaccines
Further Classification Whole-cell vaccines Whole-cell vaccines Subunit vaccines Subunit vaccines Subunit vaccines Subunit vaccines
Administration i.e., Subcutaneous, percutaneous, oral, intranasal i.e., Intramuscular, intradermal, subcutaneous i.e., Intramuscular i.e., Intramuscular, subcutaneous i.e., Intramuscular i.e., Intramuscular,
Mucosal
Production − Bacteria applications
+ Virus culture
+ Large-scale production
− Biocontainment
+ Low-cost production
+ Large-scale production
− Toxin purification procedures
− High-cost production
+ Bacterial capsule components
− Biocontainment
− Protein folding
− Protein degradation
+ Encapsulation
+ Molecular stability
+ Low-cost production
+ Encapsulation
Immunogenicity + Natural infection
+ Immunization efficiency
+ Single or few doses
+ Life-long protection
+ Natural infection
− Multiple doses
− Adjuvant use
+ Long-term
protection
− Multiple doses
− Adjuvant use
+ Molecular pathogen
− Multiple doses
− Adjuvant use
+ Stimulus by Conjugation
− Multiple doses
− Adjuvant use
+ Particle design
− Multiple doses
− Adjuvant use
+ Animal applications
− Human applications
+ Particle design
Biosafety − Risk of infection
− Risk of reversion
− Risk for the immuno-incompetent
+ Safer than LAVs + Fewer side effects
(i.e., local and systemic)
+ No live pathogenic components
+ Fewer side effects
+ No live components
+ Fewer side effects
− Autoimmune response
− Integration to genome
− Indel mutations
Storage and Transportation − Cold chain delivery − Cold chain delivery + Less need for cold chain delivery + Less need for cold chain delivery + Less need for cold chain delivery + Less need for cold chain delivery + Less need for cold chain delivery
Licensed vaccines (trade names) M-M-R II, OPV, FluMist, Rotarix, ProQuad, Adenovirus, Zostavax Pediarix, Ipol, BioThrax, Infanrix, Daptacel, Gardasil, Cervarix, Flublok Decavac, Tenivac Menomune, Pneumovax 23 PedvaxHIB, Hiberix, Comvax, Prevnar 13 Engerix-B, Recombivax HB