Skip to main content
. 2009 Sep 19;37(10):535–540. doi: 10.1016/j.mpmed.2009.07.012

Table 2.

Advantages and disadvantages of different molecular diagnostic techniques

Technique Advantages Disadvantages
PCR and its modifications
  • -

    Suitable for the detection of wide variety of pathogens with various modifications

  • -

    Suitable for a wide variety of specimen materials

  • -

    In comparison to antibody or antigen detection far more sensitive and specific

  • -

    Specimen contamination will lead to false-positive results

  • -

    More expensive than, e.g., serological methods

  • -

    Requires meticulous working techniques and quality control

  • -

    Requires special facilities and instrumentation

Isothermal amplification
  • In addition to PCR:

  • -

    Very efficient method

  • -

    NASBA is not affected by possible DNA contamination of the sample

  • In addition to PCR:

  • -

    Expensive

Fluorescence in situ hybridization
  • -

    Allows the detection of nucleic acid directly from the sample without prior nucleic acid amplification

  • -

    Low cost

  • -

    Modest technical requirements

  • -

    The technical part of the analysis is quick

  • -

    Laboratory contamination of the sample is not an issue

  • -

    Usually very specific

  • -

    Poor sensitivity

  • -

    Screening of slides slow, unless an expensive automated microscope is available

Genotyping
  • -

    Suitable for identifying antimicrobial resistance and high-risk strains

  • -

    Direct sequencing provides accurate and extensive data

  • -

    Can be used for phylogenetic analyses

  • -

    Direct sequencing requires expensive equipment and technical expertise

  • -

    Laborious method

Mass spectrometry
  • -

    Suitable for typing

  • -

    Allows detection of both known and new mutations

  • -

    Very fast compared to DNA sequencing

  • -

    Suitable for analysis of large number of samples

  • -

    Not suitable for the analysis of long oligonucleotides due to decreased sensitivity

  • -

    Cannot be used for large-scale genomic sequence analysis

  • -

    MALDI is susceptible to metal contaminants

Microarrays
  • -

    Can detect both nucleic acids and antibodies

  • -

    Very good sensitivity

  • -

    Ability to detect several pathogens simultaneously

  • -

    High sample throughput

  • -

    Too expensive to be adapted for routine diagnostics

  • -

    Usually requires nucleic acid amplification prior to analysis

PCR: polymerase chain reaction, NASBA: nucleic acid sequence based amplification, MALDI: matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization.