Table 2.
Reverse vaccinology/functional/structural genomics approaches: features and limitations
| Approach | Features | Limitations |
|---|---|---|
| Reverse vaccinology | ||
| Classical | Fast | It cannot be used to develop vaccines on the basis of nonprotein-coding antigens, like lipopolysaccharides |
| Comprehensive: it can virtually identify all potential antigens in a pathogen's genome, irrespective of their abundance, phase of expression and immunogenicity | It needs animal models, because there is a potential lack of method to measure in vitro efficacy | |
| It could be used against all pathogens, including those that cannot be grown in vitro | It lacks of information on gene expression | |
|
Pan-genomic |
Very exhaustive | It requires the sequences of multiple isolates |
| It performs interspecies and intraspecies comparisons | It needs a crucial selection of very representative strains of a given microorganism | |
| It could be useful to develop universal vaccines |
||
| Functional genomics | ||
| Transcriptomics | Very comprehensive | There is not a direct correlation between mRNA and protein expression level |
| It provides indications on semiquantitative data of genes expressed during infection | It does not give information on protein localization and gene expression regulation at the transcriptional level | |
| It can identify pathogenicity factors | It requires a high number of bacteria | |
|
Proteomics |
It provides qualitative and quantitative data on protein expression | It could identify only a fraction of all proteins |
| It can identify membrane-associated proteins | It requires a large number of bacteria cells | |
| It is time-consuming and expensive |
||
| Structural genomics | ||
| It can provide insights into protein structure, create comparative models of the most similar proteins and assign a previously unknown molecular function to a protein, providing the opportunity to recognize homologies undetectable by sequence comparison | It is practically limited to comparative modeling for evolutionarily related proteins, with consequent problems for accurate protein model in case of low sequence similarity (less than 30%) | |
| It can provide a complete understanding of molecular interactions | It needs the implementing of de novo protein structure prediction for unique folds determination in the case of sequences that are divergent from those already in the Protein Data Bank | |
| It can help the rational design of target epitopes to be used as vaccine candidates and increase the understanding of immune recognition mechanisms | Structural genomics efforts often study individual protein domains rather than whole protein or complexes | |