Table 1.
Characteristics of the datasets included in meta-analysis of candidate whole blood transcriptional signatures for incipient tuberculosis
Samples included | Study design | Population | Setting | HIV status | Sampling | Follow-up duration and method | Tuberculosis case definition | RNA sequencing methods | Newcastle-Ottawa Scale score | Baseline tuberculosis assessment | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
London tuberculosis contacts26 | 324 (8 tuberculosis; 316 healthy) | Cohort | Adult tuberculosis contacts | London, UK | Negative | Baseline | Median 1·9 (IQR 1·7– 2·2) years, record linkage | Culture-confirmed, or clinically diagnosed | 15–20 million 41 bp paired-end reads | 7/7 | Clinical evaluation and chest x-ray |
Adolescent Cohort Study24 | 287 (73 tuberculosis; 214 healthy) | Nested case-control | Adolescents with latent tuberculosis infection | South Africa | Negative | Serial (0, 6, 12, and 24 months) | 2 years, active | Intrathoracic disease with 2 positive smears, or 1 positive culture | 30 million 50 bp paired-end reads | 9/9 | Clinical evaluation; tuberculosis <6 months from enrolment excluded; chest x-ray not specified |
Grand Challenges 6-7425 | 412 (98 tuberculosis; 314 healthy) | Nested case-control | Adult household pulmonary tuberculosis contacts | South Africa, The Gambia, Ethiopia | Negative | Serial (0, 6, and 18 months) | 2 years, active | Culture-confirmed or clinically diagnosed | 60 million 50 bp paired-end reads | 9/9 | Clinical evaluation; tuberculosis <3 months from enrolment excluded; chest x-ray not specified |
Leicester tuberculosis contacts17 | 103 (4 tuberculosis; 99 healthy) | Cohort | Adult tuberculosis contacts | Leicester, UK | Negative | Baseline plus serial for a subset* | 2 years, active | Confirmed by culture or Xpert MTB/RIF | 25 million 75 bp paired-end reads | 7/7 | Clinical evaluation and chest x-ray |
Owing to the high frequency of serial sampling (<6-monthly), only baseline samples were included.