Skip to main content
. 2020 Mar 20;2020:8506591. doi: 10.1155/2020/8506591

Table 2.

Characteristics of the included studies.

First author Sample size (observation/control) Dropout rate Intervention (in the observation group) Intervention (in the control group) Course of treatment The main outcomes
Irnich et al. [16] 50 (25/25) None Verum acupuncture: LI 4, LI 10, SJ 5, SI 3, GB 34 Sham acupuncture: points: one thumb, with away from those used in the observation group 3 treatments within 10 days Pressure pain threshold (PPT)
Pain-free grip strength (GS)
NRS (same to VAS, assessment on pain on 0–10 scale)
All assessments after treatments and 14-day follow-up

Fink et al. [17] 45 (23/22) 3 at 2-week and 2 more at 2-month follow-up Verum acupuncture: LI 10, LI 11, Lu 5, LI 4, SJ 5, one A-Shi point Sham acupuncture: points: 5 cm away from the points used in the observation group 10 treatments 2 times/week within 5 weeks Pain reduction percentage
VAS (pain assessed at rest, in motion, during exertion, and frequency on 0–5 scale)
Functional impairment assessed with DASH questionnaire
All assessments after treatments and 2-month follow-up

Molsberger and Hille [15] 48 (24/24) None Verum acupuncture: GB 34 (on ipsilateral leg) Sham acupuncture: (stimulation with pencil-like probe to simulate needle insertion)
Acupuncture point UB 13
1 treatment Clinical efficacy rate
VAS (pain assessed on 0–10 scale)
Pain relief score

Haker and Lundeberg [18] 82 (44/38) 4 after 10th treatment
Another 5 at 3 months
Verum acupuncture: LI 10, LI 11, LI 12, Lu 5, SJ 10 Sham acupuncture: same acupoints but superficial needle insertion 10 treatments in all 2-3 times/week Clinical efficacy rate, the vigorimeter test
Assessments after treatments, at 3-month and 1-year follow-up

Liao Leshan [19] 60 (30/30) None Acupuncture therapy: LI10, SJ 5, LI 4, LI 12 (affected side), once a day, 2 weeks Blocking therapy: local injection of 0.5 ml triamcinolone acetate A injection plus 3 ml lidocaine, once a week, 2 weeks 10 treatments in the observation group
3 treatments in the control group
Clinical efficacy rate
Zhang Xiaoyang and Huang [20] 60 (30/30) None Acupuncture therapy: LI11, LI10, LI13, LI 1, Ah-Shi, LI3 once every other day, 2 weeks Blocking therapy: local injection of 1% 4 ml lidocaine injection and 1 ml prednisolone at tenderness point and LI11 once for ten days, 2 weeks 10 treatments in the observation group
2 treatments in the control group
Clinical efficacy rate,
VAS (pain assessed on 0–10 scale)
Elbow joint activity score (rotation function assessed on 0–8 scale)
All assessments after first therapy, all treatments and at 1-month follow-up

Min [21] 72 (36/36) None Acupuncture therapy: points: the most tenderness point, three points around the tenderness points, and LI11. Once every other day, 2 weeks Blocking therapy: local injection of 2% 1.5 ml procaine injection and 5 ml prednisolone suspension at tenderness point once for ten days, 2 weeks 10 treatments in the observation group
2 treatments in the control group
Clinical efficacy rate
VAS (pain assessed on 0–10 scale)
Both assessments after treatments and 2-month follow-up

Hongrui [14] 235 (147/88) None Acupuncture therapy: LI4, LI7, LI9, LI10 (affected side) once a day, 3 times a week, 3 weeks Blocking therapy: local injection of 1% 4 ml lidocaine injection and 50 mg prednisolone at tenderness point, once a week, 3 weeks 9 treatments in the observation group
3 treatments in the control group
Clinical efficacy rate

Yuanli [22] 84 (42/42) None Electroacupuncture therapy: cervical Jiaji 5–7 (EX-B2, affected side), SI 11, A-Shi points, LI 11, LI 10, SJ 5 once a day, 5 times a week, 2 weeks Drug therapy group: oral meloxicam tablets 7.5 mg once a day for 2 weeks 10 treatments in the observation group
14 treatments in the drug group
Clinical efficacy rate
VAS (pain assessed on 0–10 scale)
Elbow function score scale (function assessed on 0–100 scale)

Hui [13] 60 (30/30) None Acupuncture therapy: points: 4 points at 0.5 cm away from the tenderness point at 3, 6, 9, 12 o'clock, once every other day, 2 weeks Drug therapy group: oral celecoxib capsules 200 mg and external application of votalin ointment twice a day, 2 weeks 7 times in the observation group
28 times in the drug group
Clinical efficacy rate
VAS (pain assessed on 0–10 scale)
Both assessments after treatments and 3-month follow-up