Skip to main content
. 2009 Mar 10;27(21):2781–2788. doi: 10.1016/j.vaccine.2009.02.100

Table 3.

Morbidity due to respiratory disease and otitis media in vaccinated and control calves.

Vaccinated
Control
P
% No. % No.
Herd B
 Respiratory only 22 18/81 31 26/85 0.222
 All respiratory 47 38/81 42 36/85 0.555
 Otitis media only 5 4/81 1 1/85 0.202
 All otitis media 30 24/81 12 10/85 0.004
 Arthritisa 3 2/81 5 4/85 0.682
 All MbAD 54 44/81 47 40/85 0.350



Herd C
 Respiratory only 43 35/82 31 25/80 0.132
 All respiratory 67 55/82 64 51/80 0.657
 Otitis media only 4 3/82 5 4/80 0.718
 All otitis media 28 23/82 38 30/80 0.200
 Arthritis 0 0/82 0 0/80
 All MbAD 71 58/82 69 55/80 0.784



Herds B and Cb
 Respiratory only 33 53/163 31 51/165 0.755
 All respiratory 57 93/163 53 87/165 0.431
 Otitis media only 4 7/163 3 5/165
 All otitis media 29 47/163 24 40/165
 Arthritis 1 2/163 2 4/165 0.685
 All MbAD 63 102/163 58 95/165

Results are expressed as the number of calves with disease/total number of calves in that group. Herd A calves were excluded as no morbidity was observed in these animals. “All respiratory” includes calves that were treated for respiratory disease alone or for respiratory disease in conjunction with either otitis media or arthritis. “All otitis media” includes calves that were treated for otitis media alone or for otitis media in conjunction with either respiratory disease or arthritis. MbAD = Mycoplasma bovis-associated disease.

a

One control calf with arthritis also had respiratory disease.

b

Combined (Herds B and C) analyses were not performed for data that included otitis media because of the interaction between vaccination and Herd for this outcome.