Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2021 Apr 1.
Published in final edited form as: Nat Rev Earth Environ. 2020 Aug 25;1(10):544–553. doi: 10.1038/s43017-020-0080-8

Table 1. Soil indicators, inclusion in ecosystem service assessments, indicator type and assessment methods.

Indicators included in more than 20% of soil health assessments are labelled as ‘>20%’. Those included in at least one but less than 20% of assessment methods are labelled as ‘<20%’. Those that are typically not included, but recommended to be included, are labelled as ‘proposed’. Those indicators less directly relevant for a certain ecosystem service are marked as ‘-‘, those that are more relevant with ‘+’.

Ecosystem service
Indicator Inclusion Plant production Water quality Human health Climate control Type of indicator Methods to assess
N/S/P-mineralizing enzyme activity <20% + + - + B Colorimetry, extraction; lab-on-a-chip; electrochemistry
N mineralization > 20% + + - + B Incubation; extractions; lab-on-a-chip; electrochemistry
Microbial biomass > 20% + + - + B Incubation; extractions; lab-on-a-chip; electrochemistry
Pathogens Proposed + + + - B Extractions; optical analyses; lab-on-a-chip; color reactions; DNA probes; electrochemistry
Biodiversity Proposed + + + + B Extractions; bioassays; metagenomics; high-throughput sequencing; Phospholipid fatty acid; lab-on-a-chip
Microbial activity > 20% + + + + B Incubation; lab-on-a-chip; electrochemistry; biosensors
Parasites Proposed - - + - B Extractions; bioassays; metagenomics; high-throughput sequencing; screening for pathogenicity genes; lab-on-a-chip; electrochemistry; ultrasound
Fauna Proposed + + + + B Extractions; bioassays; metagenomics; high-throughput sequencing; lab-on-a-chip; electrochemistry; sound
Earthworms < 20% + - + - B Extractions; lab-on-a-chip; sound
GHG emissions Proposed - - - + B In-field and laboratory GHG sensors; robots; lab-on-a-chip; biosensors
Organic toxins Proposed + + + - C Extractions; passive samplers; lab-on-a-chip; electrochemistry
Organic C fractions < 20% + + - + C Near/mid infrared spectroscopy; density & size fractionation; oxidation
Norg fractions < 20% + + - + C Protein assay; near/mid infrared spectroscopy; density & size fractionation
Organic carbon > 20% + + + + C Near/mid infrared spectroscopy; combustion; ultrasound
Bio-available nutrients > 20% + + + + C Near/mid infrared spectroscopy; extractions; passive samplers; colorimetry; electrochemistry
pH > 20% + + + + C Near/mid infrared spectroscopy; extractions; passive samplers; colorimetry; electrochemistry
CEC > 20% + + - - C Near/mid infrared spectroscopy; extractions; passive samplers; colorimetry; electrochemistry
EC > 20% + + + - C Near/mid infrared spectroscopy; extractions; passive samplers; colorimetry; electrochemistry
Compound diversity Proposed - + - + C Spectroscopy
Mobile nutrients > 20% - + - + C Near/mid infrared spectroscopy; extractions; passive samplers; colorimetry; electrochemistry
Heavy metal toxins > 20% + + + - C Near/mid infrared spectroscopy; extractions; passive samplers; bioassays; lab-on-a-chip; biosensors; electrochemistry
Pore size diversity Proposed - + - + P Near/mid infrared spectroscopy; ultrasound
Aggregation < 20% + + - + P Sieving; near/mid infrared spectroscopy; ultrasound; visible imaging; infiltrometry
Water storage < 20% + + + + P Near/mid infrared spectroscopy; pressure plate
Penetration resistance > 20% + + - + P Penetrometry; mid infrared spectroscopy
Infiltration < 20% + + + + P Near/mid infrared spectroscopy; ultrasound; visible imaging; infiltrometer

B: biological; C: chemical; P: physical; N: nitrogen; OC: organic carbon; CEC: cation exchange capacity; EC: electrical conductivity; Norg : organic nitrogen

proportion from ref. 6

broad categories are given; for some detailed methods have been proposed (see ref. 106), others are suggestion for future exploration