Table 1.
Natural | Characteristics/chemical structure | Functionalities/derivates | Crosslinking/fabrication approaches | Remarks/biological activity |
---|---|---|---|---|
Polypeptides | ||||
Gelatin | Denaturated collagen Mainly collagen I Gly-Pro-X (most abundant) Type A (derived from acidic-treated gelatin) → positive-charge at neutral pH Type B (derived from alkali-treated gelatin) → negative-charge at neutral pH Thermoreversible gelation |
Without functionalization[35–37] | Blending with stabilizing component (e.g., alginate, fibrin[37]) Enzymatic crosslinking: transglutaminase[38] tyrosinase[39] Radical (photo-) polymerization |
Biodegradable Cell adhesion motifs are present Moderate biological activity if used alone Common sources: Bovine skin Porcine skin Fish skin |
Methacrylated[23,40-44]
Allylated[45] Norbornenet[46] Thiolatedt[47,48] Tyraminet[49] Furfury[50] |
Radical (photo-) polymerization | |||
Collagen type I | Most abundant collagen in human body Gly-Pro-X pH-dependent fibrillogenesis and gelation |
Without functionalization | pH-dependent crosslinking[51–53] photo-crosslinking (e.g., with ribofavin[54]) crosslinked with genipin[55] | Biodegradable Cell adhesion motifs are present Common sources: Rat tail Bovine skin Rabbit skin Calf skin |
Fibrinogen/fibrin | Fibrous and nonglobular glycoprotein Thrombin (factor IIa) and factor XIIIa can be used to covalently crosslink fibrinogen |
Without functionalization[18,35–37,43,51] | Enzymatic crosslinking (factor IIa, XIIIa and IV) Additionally blended with stabilizing component (e.g., gelatin, hyaluronic acid, and Pluronic F127[37]) | Biodegradable Cell adhesion motifs are present Limited long-term stability (can be prolonged by addition of aprotinin to culture medium) Common sources: Human plasma Bovine plasma Rat plasma |
Silk/fibroin | Silkworm cocoons Gly-Ser-Gly-Ala-Gly-Ala units[56] Recombinant spider protein GSSAAAAAAAASGPGGYGPE NQGPSGPGGYGPGGP Physical crosslinking by β-sheet crystal formation | Without functionalization | Physical crosslinking[57]
Blended with stabilizing component (e.g., gelatin[57]) Enzymatic crosslinking by tyrosinase[39] |
Biodegradable Poor cell adhesion due to hydrophobic character[58]
Common sources: B. mori silkworm Recombinant silk protein eADF4(C16) mimicking Araneus diadematus silk protein sequences[59] |
Poly-saccharides | ||||
Agarose | d-Galactose and 3,6-anhydro-l-galactopyranose Thermoreversible gelation | Without functionalization[60,61] | Physical crosslinking | Biologically inert Biodegradable Often used as sacrifcial material[12] Can be used to modulate the viscosity[60] Common sources: Red algae |
Alginate | Varying sequences and blocks of β-d-mannuronate (M) and α-l-guluronate (G) Ionic gelation by divalent cations (e.g., Ca[2+]) |
Without functionalization | Physical crosslinking via divalent ions Often blended with, e.g., GelMA, nanocellulose or agarose[40,44,60,62] to improve properties |
Biologically inert Sulfate can bind growth factors, such as FGF, TGF, and HFG Common sources: Brown algae |
Sulfated[63]
Methacrylated[64] |
Radical (photo-) polymerization | |||
Characteristics/chemical structure | Functionalities/derivates | Crosslinking/fabrication approaches | Remarks/biological activity | |
Hyaluronic acid | Glycosaminoglycan (GAG) Units of d-glucuronic acid and N-acetyl-d-glucosamine Forms weak entangled molecular network[65] | Without functionalization[37,66] | Needs modifcation or blending with stabilizing component | Biodegradable Cell adhesion motifs are present Can be used to modulate the viscosity Common sources: Bacteria Bovine vitreous humor Rooster comb |
Methacrylated[41,67–69]
Phenolic hydroxyl[49] Thiolated[47,48] |
Radical (photo-) polymerization | |||
Poly(N-isopropylacrylamide)[67]
Adamantane (guest)[68] β-Cyclodextrin (host) Cucurbituril (host)[70] 1,6-diaminohexane (guest) |
Lower critical solution temperature behavior (LCST) Guest–host supramolecular assembly |
|||
Gellan gum | Tetrasaccharide of repeating units of β-d-glucose, one β-d-glucuronic acid and one α-l-rhamnose[71]
Ionic gelation by mainly divalent cations Thermoreversible gelation |
Without functionalization | Physically crosslinked by cations Blended with stabilizing component (e.g., GelMA[42,72]) | Biodegradable Can be used to modulate the viscosity Common sources: Bacteria |
Nano-cellulose | Linear linked d-glucose units Cellulose nanocrystals (CNC) Cellulose nanofibers (CNF) Bacterial nanocellulose (BNC) | Without functionalization | Blended with stabilizing and/or bioactive component (e.g., algi-nate[63,73,74]
or hyaluronic acid[62,75]) |
Biodegradable Can be used to modulate the viscosity Common sources: Plants Bacteria |
Dextran | Branched or linear poly-α-d-glucose | Methacrylatedt[66] | Radical (photo-) polymerization | Biologically inert |
Chitosan | Progressively deacetylated chitins Linear and random dispersed β-(1-4)-linked d-glucosamine and N-acetyl-d-glucosamine Long gelation time and low mechanical properties[76] | Without functionalization | Blended with stabilizing components (e.g., agarose and alginate[60]) | Biodegradable[77]
improves cell survival[60] cell adhesion properties controlled by N-acetylation groups[78] antibacterial ability[79] Common sources: Chitin shells of seafood (e.g., crabs, shrimps, and prawns) |
Carboxymethylated[60]
(water soluble) |
||||
Chondroitin sulfate | Sulfated glycosaminoglycan (GAG) units of N-acetylgalactosamine and glucuronic acid | Methacrylatedt[67] | Radical (photo-) polymerization | Biodegradable Common sources: bovine trachea Shark cartilage |
Carrageenan | Kappa-carrageenan Ionic gelation mainly by potassium ions iota-carrageenan ionic gelation mainly by calcium ions Thermoreversible gelation |
Without functionalization[80] | Physically crosslinked by cations Blended with a secondary component for covalent polymer network[80]
or nanosilicates[81] |
Kappa-carrageenan mostly used due to its resemblance to natural glycosaminoglycans (GAGs)[82]
Common sources: Red algae |
Methacrylatedt[83] | Radical (photo-) polymerization | |||
Characteristics/chemical structure | Functionalities/derivates | Crosslinking/fabrication approaches | Remarks/biological activity | |
ECM mixtures | ||||
Matrigel | Solubilized basement membrane preparation Mainly laminin (L-111) and collagen IV, but in total over 1851 unique proteins and over 14 060 unique peptides[84] Temperature-dependent gelation at around RT-37 °C |
Without functionalization | Temperature-triggered gelation | Biodegradable Cell adhesion motifs are present Highly bioactive due to growth factors and vast amount of proteins and peptides No defned composition Batch-to-batch variations Common sources: Engelbreth–Holm–Swarm mouse sarcoma |
dECM | Decellularized extracellular matrix of a specifc tissue like heart,[85–87]
cartilage,[85] adipose,[85,88,89] aorta,[90] skeletal muscle,[91] and liver[92] Temperature-dependent gelation |
Without functionalization | Temperature-triggered gelation Blended with stabilizing component (e.g., thiolated gelatin, hyaluronic acid, and PEGDA[29]) Vitamin B2-induced UV-A crosslinking[86] | Biodegradable Cell adhesion motifs are present Biodegradable Highly bioactive No defned composition Batch-to-batch variations Common sources: mammalian tissue |
Synthetic | ||||
PEG | Poly(ethylene glycol) H(OCH2CH2)nOH Linear or branched | Diacrylatedt[18]
Tetra-acrylatedt[44,48] |
Radical (photo-) polymerization | Biologically inert |
Methacrylated[61]
Fibrinogen and diacrylate functionalization[18] |
||||
Succinimidyl valeratet[43] | Amin-carboxylic acid coupling (NHS ester reaction) with, e.g., proteins | |||
Pluronic | Triblock copolymer of poly(ethylene oxide) Nonionic tenside |
Without functionalization[37] | Temperature-triggered gelation | Biologically inert Often used as sacrifcial material[37] Not suitable for long-term cell culture |
Diacrylated[93] | Radical (photo-) polymerization | |||
Additives | ||||
Nanosilicates | Laponite Na[+] 07[(Mg5.5Li0.3)Si8O20(OH)4]-0.7) |
Without functionalization[83,94] | Physically crosslinked Blended with other bioink components (e.g., kappa-carrageenan and GelMA[95] | Used to modulate the viscosity of an ink to improve printability Can improve cell adhesion and response[96–98] |
Glycerol | C3H8O3
Viscous and hygroscopic liquid Backbone of many lipids |
Without functionalization | Blended with other bioink components | Can help to induce crosslinking of silk[57]
Can prevent nozzle clogging and used as rheology modifer[37] |