Chan 2001.
Clinical features and settings | Hospital setting (University of Malaya Medical Center, Malaysia) Clinical features for study inclusion: fever > 37.5 °C with respiratory symptoms and chest signs or chest radiograph changes compatible with a diagnosis of pneumonia |
|
Participants | Children aged 1 month to 15 years with community‐acquired pneumonia Number of participants: 170 Male participants: 112, (65.9%) Number of participants with M. pneumoniae: 40 (23.5%) |
|
Study design | Prospective observational cohort study | |
Target condition and reference standard(s) | M. pneumoniae detected based on serological testing of acute and convalescent blood samples taken 2 to 4 weeks apart (passive particle agglutination test). Presence of M. pneumoniae infection defined as single antibody titre of more than 1:160 or a fourfold or greater rise in antibody titre between acute and convalescent samples. The antibody titre threshold used to diagnose M. pneumoniae on a single serum sample was adjusted from 1:40 (manufacturer's recommendation) to 1:160. A titre of 1:40 was considered too low, as this was found in 45% of healthy blood donors. However, a titre of 1:160 was only found in 10% of the healthy population | |
Index and comparator tests | Wheeze | |
Follow‐up | Children followed up during admission. Duration between admission and recording of clinical features/initial sample taking was not reported | |
Notes | Extra‐pulmonary complications were encountered in 3 children with M. pneumoniae. Two children had elevated liver enzymes which normalised after a week and one died from multi‐organ failure on day 15 of illness | |
Table of Methodological Quality | ||
Item | Authors' judgement | Description |
Representative spectrum? All tests | Unclear | Co‐morbidities in study population were not reported. Did not state whether or not children with co‐morbidities were excluded |
Acceptable reference standard? All tests | Yes | M. pneumoniae detected based on serological testing of acute and convalescent blood samples taken 2 to 4 weeks apart |
Acceptable delay between tests? All tests | Unclear | Timing of collection of acute blood sample in relation to recording of clinical features was not reported |
Partial verification avoided? All tests | Yes | All study participants were subjected to the same laboratory tests |
Differential verification avoided? All tests | Yes | All study participants were subjected to the same laboratory tests |
Incorporation avoided? All tests | Yes | Clear thresholds for positive serological diagnosis of M. pneumoniae reported |
Reference standard results blinded? All tests | Yes | Clinical symptoms and signs were recorded during the acute community‐acquired pneumonia illness episode, when the results of convalescent serum samples would not have been available |
Index test results blinded? All tests | Yes | Clear thresholds for positive serological diagnosis of M. pneumoniae reported |
Relevant clinical information? All tests | Yes | Baseline data were collected from participants on age, sex, ethnicity and duration of illness |
Uninterpretable results reported? All tests | No | No intermediate or borderline serology results reported. Study did not provide definition of intermediate or borderline serology result |
Withdrawals explained? All tests | Yes | Data reported for all 170 participants; no withdrawals |