Skip to main content
. 2020 Jan 15;27(10):10553–10564. doi: 10.1007/s11356-020-07691-x

Table 6.

Granger block exogeneity results

Excluded Chi square df Prob
Dependent variable: RGDP
  LNFDI 5.522** 1 0.0188
  LNIND 0.498 1 0.4806
  LNCOAL 3.623** 1 0.0570
  LNTNR 16.479*** 1 0.0000
  All 68.697*** 4 0.0000
Dependent variable: LNFDI
  LNGDP 0.5782 1 0.4470
  LNIND 0.809 1 0.3682
  LNCOAL 5.763** 1 0.0164
  LNTNR 4.532** 1 0.0333
  All 17.955*** 4 0.0013
Dependent variable: LNIND
  LNGDP 0.831 1 0.3619
  LNFDI 4.470** 1 0.0345
  LNCOAL 0.375 1 0.5402
  LNTNR 13.188*** 1 0.0003
  All 48.829*** 4 0.0000
Dependent variable: LNCOAL
  LNGDP 1.398 1 0.2370
  LNFDI 9.364*** 1 0.0022
  LNIND 4.334** 1 0.0374
  LNTNR 3.394** 1 0.0654
  All 292.542*** 4 0.0000
Dependent variable: LNTNR
  LNGDP 1.516 1 0.2183
  LNFDI 4.374** 1 0.0365
  LNIND 0.896 1 0.3438
  LNCOAL 0.053 1 0.8176
  All 145.396*** 4 0.0000

***Significance at 0.01

**Significance at 0.05