Skip to main content
. 2020 Apr 2;10:5827. doi: 10.1038/s41598-020-62053-4

Table 4.

Comparison results of ozone simulations in HCMC with other studies.

Studies Conducted period EI method Model Prevailing wind direction Plume direction Maximum concentration
(Nghiem, 2009)24 Three days in Jan 2005 Top-down approach, data were collected from satellite image (MODIS) in 2005 CMAQ-MM5 Northerly Southwest 50 ppb
(Dung, 2009)10 Two days in Jan 2006 Top-down and bottom-up approach, data were calculated for on-road, industrial, and domestic sources FVM-TAPOM Northerly Southwest 75 ppb
(Bang, 2011)11 Three days in Feb 2006 Top-down and bottom-up approach, data were calculated for on-road, industrial, and domestic sources FVM-TAPOM Easterly Northern and Northwestern 150 ppb
(Bang, 2018)15 Entire one-month period in Jan 2015 Top-down and bottom-up approach, data were calculated for traffic, industrial, household, and biogenic sources TAPM-CTM Northerly Southwest 65 ppb
This study Entire 1-year period in 2017, the maximum concentration occurred in Dec 2017 Top-down and bottom-up approach, data were calculated for line source (including on-road and non-road such as airport, seaport, and bus station; area sources including household, restaurants, gas station, etc.; point sources and biogenic sources TAPM-CTM Northerly Southwest 110 ppb