Table 3.
Chronic rhinosinusitis in children
| Author | Criteria | No. | Age (y) | Sterilization | Quantitation | Off antibiotics | Microbiology |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Brook, 198139 | ≥21 d | 40 | 6–16 | Yes | No | Yes | • 37/40 = +cx |
| • Anaerobes in all (GPC, GPR, GNR) | |||||||
| • Aerobes in 38% (GPC) | |||||||
| Otten and Grote, 198841 | ≥90 (purulent d/c) | 141 | 3–10 | NA | NA | NA | • 70% +cx: Usual acute flora |
| Tinkleman and Silk, 198946 | ≥30 d | 35 | 0.9–16 | Yes | Yes | No | • 63% +cx: Usual acute flora |
| Muntz and Lusk, 199145 | NA | 105 | 0.7–17 | NA | No (mucosa) | No | • Contaminants: majority |
| • Acute agents ∼ minority | |||||||
| • Bx of ethmoid cultured | |||||||
| Orobello et al, 1991*43 | ≥42 d (or recurrent) | 39 | 1.2–19 | Yes | Semi (irrigation) | No | • Contaminants: majority |
| • Usual acute flora: very light density | |||||||
| Otten, 1994*42 | ≥90 d (purulent d/c) | 79 | 2–12 | NA | No | Yes | • Usual pathogens |
| Brook et al, 2000*40 | ≥90 d (purulent) | 32 | 4–11 | Yes | No (irrigation) | Yes | • Usual pathogens and anaerobes |
| Slack et al, 200047 | ≥56 d | 119 | 0.8–14.5 | No | No (irrigation) | No | • Usual pathogens |
| • Occasional contaminants | |||||||
| Don et al, 200144 | ≥90 d | 70 | 0.9–15 | Yes | No (irrigation) | No | • Usual pathogens (60%) |
| • Contaminants |
Contaminants: CNS, α-strep, and coagulase-positive staphylococci.
+cx, Positive culture; GPC, gram-positive cocci; GPR, gram-positive rods; GNR, gram-negative rods; d/c, discharge; NA, not available; Bx, biopsy.
Prospective.