Skip to main content
. 2009 Jan 20;29(6):1996–2004. doi: 10.1016/j.wasman.2008.11.031

Table 2.

Main advantages and shortcomings of the different technologies for HCW in China (Akter, 2000).

Type Factors Advantages Disadvantages Pollutants emission Scope can be treated
Incineration/pyrolysis-gasification
  • Turbulence and mixing

  • Moisture content of waste

  • Filling combustion chamber

  • Temperature and residence time

  • Maintenance and repair

  • Mature and widely used technology

  • Volume and weight reduction

  • Unrecognizable waste

  • Complete disinfection

  • Heat recovery potential for large system

  • Broad applicability, acceptable for all waste types

  • Large scale system of waste

  • Related standards and specifications completed

  • Public opposition

  • High investment and operation costs

  • High maintenance cost

  • Expensive control equipment required to reduce emissions

  • Skilled operator needed

  • Bottom and fly ash may be hazardous

PCDD/PCDFs SO2, HCl, NOx, Heavy metals, etc. Acceptable for all waste types



High temperature steam-based
  • Waste characteristics

  • Temperature and pressure

  • Steam penetration

  • Size of waste load

  • Length and number of treatment cycles

  • Degree of vacuum in the chamber

  • Low investment cost

  • Low operating cost

  • Ease of biological tests

  • Low hazard residue

  • PCDD/PCDFs emission free

  • Appearance, volume unchanged

  • Not suitable for all waste types, chemical waste and pharmaceutical waste can not be treated

  • Possible incomplete disinfection

Microorganisms, Odour, VOCs and others Infectious waste, Pathological waste, Sharp objects



Microwave
  • Moisture content of waste

  • Microwave strength

  • Duration of exposure

  • Extent of waste mixture

  • Unrecognizable waste

  • Significant volume reduction

  • Absence of liquid discharge

  • PCDD/PCDFs emission free

  • Mod-High investment cost

  • Not suitable for all waste types, chemical waste and pharmaceutical waste can not be treated

  • Possible incomplete disinfection

Microorganisms, Odour, VOCs and others Infectious waste, Pathological waste, Sharp objects



Chemical
  • Concerns for chemicals, temperature,

  • pH

  • Chemical contact time

  • Waste and chemical mixing

  • Recirculation vs flow-through

  • Significant volume reduction

  • Unrecognizable waste

  • Rapid processing

  • Waste deodorization

  • PCDD/PCDFs emission free

  • Mod -High investment cost

  • Not suitable for all waste types, chemical waste and pharmaceutical waste can not be treated

  • Possible incomplete disinfection

  • Need for chemical storage

Microorganisms, Odour, VOCs and others Infectious waste, Pathological waste, Sharp objects