Skip to main content
. 2020 Apr 4;2020(4):CD010596. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD010596.pub3

2. Characteristics of exercise interventions for ARI.

Study ID Location Type of exercise Setting/frequency Intensity Duration Supervision Comparison group Outcomes in meta‐analysis
Barrett 2012 USA Bicycle, treadmill, and brisk walk UW Health Sports Medicine
 Center 1 group contact (2.5 hours per week) + 45 minutes home practice per day 12 to 16 Borg Scale 8 weeks Supervised by exercise physiologist Meditation and non‐exercise Number of ARI episodes, proportion of people with ARI, ARI severity, number of symptoms per day, laboratory parameters ‐ neutrophils, quality of life, cost to patient, adherence to intervention
Barrett 2018 USA Bicycle, treadmill, and brisk walk UW Health Sports Medicine
 Center 1 group contact (2.5 hours per week) + 45 minutes home practice per day 12 to 16 Borg Scale 8 weeks Supervised by experienced exercise instructors Non‐exercise Number of ARI episodes, proportion of people with ARI, ARI severity, number of symptom days, laboratory parameters ‐ neutrophils, quality of life, cost to patient, adherence to intervention
Chubak 2006 USA Bicycle, treadmill, or walk Study facilities 5 days per week; plus 2 days per week at home 45 minutes of moderate‐intensity exercise 12 months Supervised by exercise physiologist in the first 3 months Once‐weekly, 45‐minute stretching sessions Adherence; ARI episodes
Ciloğlu 2005 Turkey Walking on a treadmill or an outdoor track Indoor and outdoor exercises at university 5 days per week 30 minutes each time respectively at 60% MHR 12 weeks Supervised Outdoor exercise and non‐exercise Adherence; ARI symptoms
Dias 2014 Brazil Resistance training Gymnasium, group exercise, 3 days per week Each weight was determined subjectively. 9 weeks Supervised training Non‐exercise Adherence
Klentrou 2002 Canada Bicycles, treadmills, stair climbers, or combined Research centre, group exercise, 3 days per week 30 minutes at 75% HR reserve + 15 minutes of stretching 12 weeks Supervised Non‐exercise Adherence; ARI symptoms; salivary secretion immunoglobulin
Manzaneque 2004 Spain Qigong (traditional Chinese exercise) Research centre, group exercise, 5 days per week 8 distinct movements repeated 8 times for 30 minutes each session 4 weeks Qualified Qigong instructor Non‐exercise Adherence
Nieman 1990 USA Walking Research centre, group exercise, 5 days per week 45 minutes at 60% reserve heart rate 15 weeks Supervised Non‐exercise Adherence; ARI episodes; ARI symptoms; lymphocytes
Nieman 1993 USA Brisk walking Research centre, group activity, 5 days per week 30 to 40 minutes at 60% target heart rate 12 weeks Supervised Calisthenics Adherence; ARI episodes; lymphocytes
Nieman 1997 USA Walking Research centre, indoor group activity, 5 days per week 45 minutes at 60% to 80% reserve heart rate 12 weeks Supervised Non‐exercise Adherence; ARI symptoms; lymphocytes
Silva 2018 Portugal Resistance training and aerobic training Research centre, indoor group activity, 3 days per week 90 min (10 min of warm‐up, 30 min
 of aerobic training, and 45 min of resistance training, ending with a 5‐minute cool‐down) 36 weeks Supervised training by physical education Non‐exercise Number of ARI episodes, proportion of people with ARI, severity of ARI, number of symptoms days per episode, adherence to intervention group
Sloan 2013 USA Walking Home‐based exercise 5 days per week 30 minutes at 75% of individual HR max 16 weeks Not supervised Non‐exercise ARI episodes; adherence; ARI symptoms; salivary secretion immunoglobulin
Weidner 1998 USA Bicycle, walking, or jogging Research centre, group activity, 6 days of exercise 30 minutes at 70% of target heart rate 10 days Supervised training Non‐exercise Adherence; ARI symptoms
Weidner 2003 USA Bicycle, walking, or jogging Research centre, group activity, 5 days per week 30 minutes at 70% of target heart rate 7 days Supervised Non‐exercise Adherence

ARI: Acute Respiratory Infection
 HR: Heart Rate
 MHR: Maximal Heart Rate