2. Characteristics of exercise interventions for ARI.
Study ID | Location | Type of exercise | Setting/frequency | Intensity | Duration | Supervision | Comparison group | Outcomes in meta‐analysis |
Barrett 2012 | USA | Bicycle, treadmill, and brisk walk | UW Health Sports Medicine Center 1 group contact (2.5 hours per week) + 45 minutes home practice per day | 12 to 16 Borg Scale | 8 weeks | Supervised by exercise physiologist | Meditation and non‐exercise | Number of ARI episodes, proportion of people with ARI, ARI severity, number of symptoms per day, laboratory parameters ‐ neutrophils, quality of life, cost to patient, adherence to intervention |
Barrett 2018 | USA | Bicycle, treadmill, and brisk walk | UW Health Sports Medicine Center 1 group contact (2.5 hours per week) + 45 minutes home practice per day | 12 to 16 Borg Scale | 8 weeks | Supervised by experienced exercise instructors | Non‐exercise | Number of ARI episodes, proportion of people with ARI, ARI severity, number of symptom days, laboratory parameters ‐ neutrophils, quality of life, cost to patient, adherence to intervention |
Chubak 2006 | USA | Bicycle, treadmill, or walk | Study facilities 5 days per week; plus 2 days per week at home | 45 minutes of moderate‐intensity exercise | 12 months | Supervised by exercise physiologist in the first 3 months | Once‐weekly, 45‐minute stretching sessions | Adherence; ARI episodes |
Ciloğlu 2005 | Turkey | Walking on a treadmill or an outdoor track | Indoor and outdoor exercises at university 5 days per week | 30 minutes each time respectively at 60% MHR | 12 weeks | Supervised | Outdoor exercise and non‐exercise | Adherence; ARI symptoms |
Dias 2014 | Brazil | Resistance training | Gymnasium, group exercise, 3 days per week | Each weight was determined subjectively. | 9 weeks | Supervised training | Non‐exercise | Adherence |
Klentrou 2002 | Canada | Bicycles, treadmills, stair climbers, or combined | Research centre, group exercise, 3 days per week | 30 minutes at 75% HR reserve + 15 minutes of stretching | 12 weeks | Supervised | Non‐exercise | Adherence; ARI symptoms; salivary secretion immunoglobulin |
Manzaneque 2004 | Spain | Qigong (traditional Chinese exercise) | Research centre, group exercise, 5 days per week | 8 distinct movements repeated 8 times for 30 minutes each session | 4 weeks | Qualified Qigong instructor | Non‐exercise | Adherence |
Nieman 1990 | USA | Walking | Research centre, group exercise, 5 days per week | 45 minutes at 60% reserve heart rate | 15 weeks | Supervised | Non‐exercise | Adherence; ARI episodes; ARI symptoms; lymphocytes |
Nieman 1993 | USA | Brisk walking | Research centre, group activity, 5 days per week | 30 to 40 minutes at 60% target heart rate | 12 weeks | Supervised | Calisthenics | Adherence; ARI episodes; lymphocytes |
Nieman 1997 | USA | Walking | Research centre, indoor group activity, 5 days per week | 45 minutes at 60% to 80% reserve heart rate | 12 weeks | Supervised | Non‐exercise | Adherence; ARI symptoms; lymphocytes |
Silva 2018 | Portugal | Resistance training and aerobic training | Research centre, indoor group activity, 3 days per week | 90 min (10 min of warm‐up, 30 min of aerobic training, and 45 min of resistance training, ending with a 5‐minute cool‐down) | 36 weeks | Supervised training by physical education | Non‐exercise | Number of ARI episodes, proportion of people with ARI, severity of ARI, number of symptoms days per episode, adherence to intervention group |
Sloan 2013 | USA | Walking | Home‐based exercise 5 days per week | 30 minutes at 75% of individual HR max | 16 weeks | Not supervised | Non‐exercise | ARI episodes; adherence; ARI symptoms; salivary secretion immunoglobulin |
Weidner 1998 | USA | Bicycle, walking, or jogging | Research centre, group activity, 6 days of exercise | 30 minutes at 70% of target heart rate | 10 days | Supervised training | Non‐exercise | Adherence; ARI symptoms |
Weidner 2003 | USA | Bicycle, walking, or jogging | Research centre, group activity, 5 days per week | 30 minutes at 70% of target heart rate | 7 days | Supervised | Non‐exercise | Adherence |
ARI: Acute Respiratory Infection HR: Heart Rate MHR: Maximal Heart Rate