Skip to main content
. 2013 Sep 21;31(46):5321–5338. doi: 10.1016/j.vaccine.2013.09.029

Table 2.

Strengths and limitations of vaccination of animals as a means to control of zoonotic diseases.

Framework (See Table 1) Strengths Limitations
I Benefits to human and animal health DIVA requirements
Potential for accelerated development of new vaccines Liability concerns
Collaborations between animal and human health industry Segregated regulatory pathways
Reduced development costs Inadvertent exposure of humans to live vaccines
Additional models for Animal Rule
Lack of commercial incentive



II New approaches to disease control DIVA requirements
Benefits to human and animal health Wild animal reservoirs
Short development times and relatively low cost Persistent environmental source of infection
Accelerated regulatory pathway Durability of immune response
Potential for disease control without need for human vaccines inadvertent exposure of humans to live vaccines
Collaborations between animal and human health industry Low commercial value, reliance on government funding
Improved food safety Feral animals or small farm operations inaccessible to vaccination
High vaccine coverage required for herd immunity



III New approaches to disease control GMO issues
Control of infections acquired from wild animals Safety for non-target species
Accelerated regulatory pathway Role of animals other than target species in transmission
Potential for disease control without need for human vaccines Very high or very low target species density
Collaborations between animal and human health industry Difficulty in designing and delivering oral vaccines
Control of wildlife diseases Vaccine stability under conditions of use
Low commercial value, reliance on government funding