Skip to main content
. 2015 Jul 6;2015(7):CD002959. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD002959.pub4
Study Reason for exclusion
Abu Raya 2014 Not a trial. Serological outcomes only: antibody titre against tetanus and diphtheria in paired maternal cord sera.
Abuwa 1997 Not a trial.
Al‐Safi 2011 Narrative review.
Anh 1999 Not a trial. Serological measurement with means of the Toxin Binding Inhibition Test on pregnant women and children after 2 doses TT.
Axelsson 2002 Review on umbilical cord care and prevention of infections.
Aylward 1996 Surveillance study.
Baltazar 1994 Case‐control study on efficacy of prenatal TT immunisation in preventing neonatal tetanus.
Basher 2010 Cross‐sectional study assessing vaccination coverage and educational status in a sample of undergraduate female students in Bangladesh.
Berggren 1971 Retrospective survey.
Blencowe 2010 Systematic review.
Canning 2011 Follow‐up study assessing schooling attainment on babies born from mothers who were immunised several years earlier (Black 1980).
Chai 2004 Case‐control study.
Chongsuvivatwong 1993 Incidence of neonatal tetanus mortality before and after mass immunisation in Thailand.
de Walque 2008 Not comparative.
Dhillon 1975 Not a trial. Only serological outcomes.
Dietz 1996 Review.
Erener‐Ercan 2014 Not a trial. Serological outcomes only: antibody titre against tetanus and diphtheria in paired maternal cord sera.
Gupta 1998 Cohort study.
Halperin 2011 Interventions (vaccine or placebo) were administered after delivery (post‐partum study)
Hardy‐Fairbanks 2013 Not a trial (cohort study). Antibody titre in maternal, cord blood and infant.
Hasnain 2007 Survey assessing the reasons for low vaccination coverage.
Heredia 1968 Not a trial. Only serological assessment.
Hlady 1992 Case‐control study.
Hurmez 2012 Not a comparative study. Seroprevalence and TT vaccine coverage assessed on a sample of 600 pregnant women in Iraq.
Juan‐Giner 2014 Trial assessing antibody response to 2 TT vaccines that underwent either controlled temperature chain or standard cold chain in women between 14 and 49 years.
Kielmann 1977 Not a trial. Administration of TT with 2 different adjuvants in women of reproductive age. Only serological outcomes.
Koenig 1998 Not a trial. 10‐year follow‐up conducted on half of the area where Black 1980 was carried out.
Krishnan 2013 Study assessing whether differential excess mortality among Indian girl children could be associated with vaccinations (GBS, DTP, measles).
Lassi 2010 Cochrane review about efficacy of community‐based intervention packages to prevent neonatal tetanus. Vaccination is not included.
MacLennan 1965 No intervention: administration of vaccines containing same toxoids but different adjuvants in women of reproductive age. Efficacy outcomes are only serological.
Mulholland 1996 No intervention: trial with polyribosylribitol phosphate‐tetanus vaccine.
Nohynek 1999 No intervention: participants were children receiving conjugate Hib and DTP vaccine, who were born from mother immunised with different doses of TT (0, 1, 2, 3 and more).
Orozova‐Bekkevold 2007 Not about tetanus immunisation.
Perry 1998 Report on TT immunisation coverage.
Rahman 1982b Consensus to vaccination.
Rahman 1982a Not a trial. Vaccination of pregnant women with 3 doses of TT. Immunisation program conducted in half of the Matlab area after Black 1980.
Relyveld 1991 Only serological outcomes.
Salama 2009 Efficacy outcome is not of interest: immune response to vaccination assessed in women after immunisation.
Schofield 1961 Not a trial.
Shakib 2013 Cohort study.
Silveira 1995 Case‐control to assess relationship between exposition to TT in pregnancy and malformation in the newborns.
Stanfield 1973 Not a trial. Variation of seral antitoxin after administration of different TT preparation to pregnant women.
Suri 1964 Not a trial. Different TT preparations were administered and antitoxins in cord blood were measured.
Tall 1991 Case‐control study.
Traverso 1991 Case‐control study for assessing risk of developing neonatal tetanus, TT immunisation of the mothers was not evaluated as associated factor.
Yala 1980 Not a trial.
Yusuf 1991 Follow‐up survey to determine incidence of neonatal tetanus before and after a vaccination campaign in Indonesia.

DTP: diphtheria, tetanus and pertussis
 GBS: group B streptococcus
 Hib: H. Influenza 
 TT: tetanus toxoid