Skip to main content
. 2009 Apr 15;2009(2):CD003030. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD003030.pub2

Davis 2004.

Methods Cluster RCT 
 Follow up:
providers: DONE 
 patients: NOT DONE 
 Blinded assessment: NOT CLEAR 
 Baseline: DONE 
 Reliable outcomes: DONE 
 Protection against contamination: DONE
Overall quality: MODERATE
Participants General practitioners from 68 practices in 53 locations with 1133 of their patients 
 Country: Scotland 
 Proportion of eligible providers who participated: 91% 
 General practice
Academic/Teaching setting: NOT CLEAR 
 Type of targeted behaviour: GENERAL MANAGEMENT OF A PROBLEM (epilepsy care) 
 Complexity of targeted behaviour: MEDIUM
Interventions 1. CME intensive: postal dissemination of guideline + interactive, accredited workshops + dedicated structured protocol documents (tool to be used in patient treatment) + the services of a nurse specialist in epilepsy: who offered advice and training to practices in establishing epilepsy review programs, promoted the use of the guideline in epilepsy management and provided information on epilepsy for both practitioners and patients 
 2. CME intermediate: postal dissemination of guideline + interactive, accredited workshops + dedicated structured protocol documents (tool to be used in patient treatment) 
 3. Postal dissemination of a nationally developed guideline
Outcomes Professional practice: process of care data 
 Patient: SF‐36 general health related quality of life measures 
 Seriousness of outcome: HIGH
Notes Data on professional outcomes could not be extracted, only patient outcomes
Risk of bias
Bias Authors' judgement Support for judgement
Allocation concealment (selection bias) Low risk A ‐ Adequate