Strecher 1991.
| Methods | Cluster RCT
Follow up:
providers: DONE
patients: NOT DONE
Blinded assessment: NOT CLEAR
Baseline: NOT DONE
Reliable outcomes: NOT CLEAR
Protection against contamination: NOT DONE Overall quality: LOW |
|
| Participants | 261 residents in 11 primary care training programmes providing smoking counselling Country: USA Proportion of eligible providers who participated: 96% Hospital, outpatients Academic/Teaching setting: UNIVERSITY‐BASED Type of targeted behaviour: PREVENTIVE CARE (smoking counselling) Complexity of targeted behaviour: LOW | |
| Interventions | 1. CME: 1‐hour tutorial including 10‐min slide presentation, 10 min counselling approach, 20‐min group discussion + 1‐hour small group or individual follow up 2. Same tutorial + prompting program (chart‐based reminders) 3. Prompting program | |
| Outcomes | Professional practice: counselling frequency, mean number of five techniques used per patient, 5 counselling techniques Patient: none Seriousness of outcome: MODERATE | |
| Notes | ||
| Risk of bias | ||
| Bias | Authors' judgement | Support for judgement |
| Allocation concealment (selection bias) | Unclear risk | B ‐ Unclear |