Skip to main content
. 2020 Mar 22;21(6):2191. doi: 10.3390/ijms21062191

Table 3.

NOL-HHO results for different dimensions using functions F1–F13.

ID Metric NOL-HHO
(100dim)		 HHO
(100 dim)		 NOL-HHO
(500 dim)		 HHO
(500 dim)		 NOL-HHO
(1000 dim)		 HHO
(1000 dim)
F1 AVG 0.00 × 10+00 1.91 × 10−94 0.00 × 10+00 1.46 × 10−92 0.00 × 10+00 1.06 × 10−94
STD 0.00 × 10+00 8.66 × 10−94 0.00 × 10+00 8.01 × 10−92 0.00 × 10+00 4.97 × 10−94
F2 AVG 0.00 × 10+00 9.98 × 10−52 0.00 × 10+00 7.87 × 10−49 0.00 × 10+00 2.52 × 10−50
STD 0.00 × 10+00 2.66 × 10−51 0.00 × 10+00 3.11 × 10−48 0.00 × 10+00 5.02 × 10−50
F3 AVG 0.00 × 10+00 1.84 × 10−59 0.00 × 10+00 6.54 × 10−37 0.00 × 10+00 1.79 × 10−17
STD 0.00 × 10+00 1.01 × 10−58 0.00 × 10+00 3.58 × 10−36 0.00 × 10+00 9.81 × 10−17
F4 AVG 0.00 × 10+00 8.76 × 10−47 0.00 × 10+00 1.29 × 10−47 0.00 × 10+00 1.43 × 10−46
STD 0.00 × 10+00 4.79 × 10−46 0.00 × 10+00 4.11 × 10−47 0.00 × 10+00 7.74 × 10−46
F5 AVG 1.22 × 10−04 2.36 × 10−02 6.66 × 10−02 3.10 × 10−01 2.29 × 10−02 5.73 × 10−01
STD 5.95 × 10−03 2.99 × 10−02 4.79 × 10−02 3.73 × 10−01 1.01 × 10−01 1.40 × 10+00
F6 AVG 7.71 × 10−06 5.12 × 10−04 6.85 × 10−06 2.94 × 10−03 1.81 × 10−04 3.61 × 10−03
STD 6.62 × 10−05 6.77 × 10−04 8.04 × 10−04 3.98 × 10−01 1.02 × 10−03 5.38 × 10−03
F7 AVG 6.59 × 10−05 1.85 × 10−04 2.24 × 10−05 2.51 × 10−04 3.81 × 10−06 1.41 × 10−04
STD 3.63 × 10−05 4.06 × 10−04 2.87 × 10−05 2.43 × 10−04 5.79 × 10−05 1.63 × 10−04
F8 AVG −4.19 × 10+04 −4.19 × 10+04 −2.09 × 10+05 −2.09 × 10+05 −4.19 × 10+05 −4.19 × 10+05
STD 1.35 × 10+00 2.82 × 10+00 8.13 × 10+00 2.84 × 10+01 1.01 × 10+01 1.03 × 10+02
F9 AVG 0.00 × 10+00 0.00 × 10+00 0.00 × 10+00 0.00 × 10+00 0.00 × 10+00 0.00 × 10+00
STD 0.00 × 10+00 0.00 × 10+00 0.00 × 10+00 0.00 × 10+00 0.00 × 10+00 0.00 × 10+00
F10 AVG 8.88 × 10−16 8.88 × 10−16 8.88 × 10−16 8.88 × 10−16 8.88 × 10−16 8.88 × 10−16
STD 0.00 × 10+00 4.01 × 10−31 0.00 × 10+00 4.01 × 10−31 0.00 × 10+00 4.01 × 10−31
F11 AVG 0.00 × 10+00 0.00 × 10+00 0.00 × 10+00 0.00 × 10+00 0.00 × 10+00 0.00 × 10+00
STD 0.00 × 10+00 0.00 × 10+00 0.00 × 10+00 0.00 × 10+00 0.00 × 10+00 0.00 × 10+00
F12 AVG 2.62 × 10−09 4.23 × 10−06 1.17 × 10−10 1.41 × 10−06 1.18 × 10−08 1.02 × 10−06
STD 4.18 × 10−07 5.25× 10−06 1.02 × 10−07 1.48 × 10−06 1.94 × 10−07 1.16 × 10−06
F13 AVG 6.46 × 10−06 9.13 × 10−05 6.47 × 10−05 3.44 × 10−04 2.63 × 10−04 8.41 × 10−04
STD 1.45 × 10−05 1.26 × 10−04 1.09 × 10−04 4.75 × 10−04 1.92 × 10−04 1.18 × 10−03