Skip to main content
. 2020 Feb 3;6:100109. doi: 10.1016/j.eurox.2020.100109

Table 1.

Characteristics of included studies.

Study information
Participants
Outcomes Quality
Study Country Design Time period of data collection Number in adolescent group(s) Age Number in adult group Age Inclusion criteria Exclusion criteria Outcomes reported Quality rating
Bai 1999 Australia Retrospective cohort March 1996–June 1998 128 <18 5898 20–34 Singletons born at Liverpool Hospital, New South Wales, during the study period Less than 20 weeks gestation or birth weight less than 500 grams Preterm delivery (<37 weeks) +/−
Stillbirth
313 18–19 Low birth weight (<2500 g)
Average birth weight
Buschman 2001 UK Retrospective cohort NR 104 <16 150 25–30 Random sample from medical case notes of babies born at Tayside Hospital, Dundee Last pregnancy body weight recorded before 36 weeks gestation, age over 30 years Mean gestation at delivery +
Mean birth weight
Low birth weight (<2500 g)
El-Gilany 2012 Saudi Arabia Retrospective cohort Jan 2010 – Dec 2010 404 <20 3691 20–34 Women accessing maternity care across 40 primary health care centres in the Northern region of Saudi Arabia Files with incomplete data Preterm delivery (<37 weeks) +
Stillbirth
Low birth weight (<2500 g)
Fayed 2018 Saudi Arabia Retrospective cohort Nov 2013 - Mar 2015 296 <20 6994 20–29 Women recruited for the RAHMA multi-centre cohort study None Preterm delivery (<37 weeks) +
Preterm delivery (<34 weeks)
Stillbirth
Low birth weight (<2500 g)
Mean birth weight
APGAR <7
Fleming 2013 Canada Retrospective cohort Jan 2006 – Dec 2010 23,810 <20 523,721 20–35 Women registered on the Better Outcomes Registry and Network Ontario database Age over 35 years, stillborn, multiple births Mean gestation at delivery +
Mean birth weight
Small for gestational age
Low birth weight (<2500 g)
Preterm delivery (<37 weeks)
Preterm delivery (<32 weeks)
Gupta 2008 UK Retrospective cohort Jan 1990 – Dec 1999 587 <17 17,615 20–34 Primiparous women recruited for the Cardiff Births Survey Age over 34 years Preterm delivery (<37 weeks) +
Preterm delivery (29–32 weeks)
Preterm delivery (24–28 weeks)
4,126 <20 Low birth weight (<2500 g)
Stillbirth
Neonatal death
Perinatal death
Haldre 2007 Estonia Retrospective cohort Jan 1992 – Dec 2002 4,248 <18 35,266 20–24 Primiparous women recorded on the Estonian Medical Birth Registry Age over 24 years Preterm delivery (<37 weeks) +
Low birth weight (<2500 g)
Stillbirth
12,376 18–19 Neonatal death
Perinatal death
Jolly 2000 UK Retrospective cohort Jan 1988 – Dec 1997 5,245 <18 336,462 18–34 Singleton births recorded in the St Mary's Maternity Information System Database Age over 34 years Small for gestational age +
Preterm delivery (<37 weeks)
Preterm delivery (<32 weeks)
Stillbirth
APGAR <7
Kawakita 2016 USA Retrospective cohort Jan 2002 – Dec 2008 1,189 <16 27,645 20–24 Primiparous women with singleton pregnancies recorded in the Consortium of Safe Labor Women aged over 24 Preterm delivery (<37 weeks) +
Preterm delivery (<34 weeks)
Preterm delivery (<28 weeks)
Low birth weight (<2500 g)
14,703 16–19 Very low birth weight (<1500 g)
APGAR <7
Perinatal death
Korencan 2017 Slovenia Retrospective cohort Jan 2008 – Dec 2012 318 <18 12,112 20–24 Primiparous women recorded on the National Perinatal Information System in Slovinia Women aged over 24 Preterm delivery (<32 weeks) +
Preterm delivery (32–36 weeks)
Small for gestational age
Low birth weight (<2500 g)
1,413 <20 Very low birth weight (<1500 g)
APGAR <7
Stillbirth
Lao 2012 Hong Kong Retrospective cohort Jan 1998 – June 2008 1,505 <20 10,320 20–24 Primiparous women with singleton pregnancies delivering at Prince of Wales Hospital, Shatin, during the study period Women aged over 24 Mean gestation at delivery +
Mean birth weight
Preterm delivery (<34 weeks)
Preterm delivery (34–36 weeks)
Low birth weight (<2500 g)
APGAR <7
Stillbirth
Neonatal death
Perinatal death
Leppalahti 2013 Finland Retrospective cohort Jan 2006 – Dec 2011 84 13–15 51,142 25–29 Primiparous women with singleton pregnancies recorded on the Finish national Medical Birth Register Cases of major congenital abnormalities, women aged 20–24 or over 29 years Preterm delivery (<37 weeks) +
1,234 16–17 Preterm delivery (<28 weeks)
5,987 18–19 Small for gestational age
Stillbirth/neonatal death
Marvin-Dowle 2018 UK Retrospective cohort Mar 2007 – Dec 2010 68 <16 3,951 20–34 Primiparous women with singleton pregnancies in the Born in Bradford cohort study Women aged over 34 years Preterm delivery (<37 weeks) +
Preterm delivery (<32 weeks)
Preterm delivery (<28 weeks)
Low birth weight (<2500 g)
Very low birth weight (<1500 g)
Extremely low birth weight (<1000 g)
640 <20 Small for gestational age
APGAR <7
Stillbirth
Mean gestation at delivery
Mean birth weight
Mohsin 2006 Australia Retrospective cohort Jan 1998 – Dec 2002 19,648 <20 336,826 20–34 Births recorded in the NSW Midwives data Collection Births at less than 20 weeks gestation or with a birthweight of less than 400g Stillbirth +
O'Leary 2007 Australia Retrospective cohort Jan 1994 – Dec 2003 14,725 <20 43,810 20–24 Births recorded in the MCHRDB database Births at less than 20 weeks gestation or with a birthweight of less than 400g Stillbirth +
Neonatal death
Otterblad Olausson 1999 Sweden Retrospective cohort Jan 1973 – Dec 1989 831 13–15 259,494 20–24 Primiparous women with singleton pregnancies recorded on the Swedish Medical Birth Register Women aged over 24 years Stillbirth +
11,379 16–17 Neonatal death
Post-neonatal death
48,470 18–19 Preterm delivery (33–36 weeks)
Preterm delivery (23–32 weeks)
Papamichael 2009 UK Retrospective case-control Jan 2004 – Dec 2007 35 <16 35 20–30 The index group (all women aged <16) was draw from the North Middlesex University Hospital database and the consecutive birth to a women in the other two age groups, mached by parity and ethnicity, selected for the two control groups Not reported Small for gestational age +/−
35 16–19 Stillbirth
Smith 2001 UK Retrospective cohort Jan 1992 – Dec 1998 9699 15–19 59,315 20–29 Primiparous women recorded on the Scottish morbidity record 2 Not reported Preterm delivery (33–36 weeks) +/−
Preterm delivery (24–32 weeks)
Small for gestational age
Stillbirth
Neonatal death
Socolov 2017 Romania Retrospective cohort Jan 2007–Dec 2014 1,276 12–17 9,479 20–24 Women delivering a singleton at Cuza Voda Hospital, Iasi, during the study period Women aged over 24 years, delivery at less than 24 weeks gestation Mean gestation at delivery +
Mean birth weight
Preterm delivery (24–36 weeks)
Preterm delivery (24–34 weeks)
2,615 18–19 Preterm delivery (24–28 weeks)
Low birth weight (<2500 g)
Very low birth weight (<1500 g)
APGAR <7
Suzuki 2018 Japan Retrospective cohort Jan 2002 – Dec 2016 325 <18 2,029 28–30 Women delivering a singleton at Katsushika Maternity Hospital during the study period Delivery at less than 22 weeks gestation Preterm delivery (<37 weeks) +/−
Low birth weight (<2500 g)
Perinatal death