Skip to main content
. 2012 Feb 15;2012(2):CD003721. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD003721.pub3
Study Reason for exclusion
Amir 2010 Article is a review of risk‐assessment models
Appleton 2004b Relating to the provision of information and education
Armstrong 2005 Includes participants with a previous or current cancer diagnosis
Barcenas 2006 Relating to a risk‐assessment model rather than the provision of genetic risk assessment
Bellcross 2009 Relating to a genetics referral screening tool, not the provision of a genetic risk assessment
Bluman 1999 Survey of baseline data ‐ not the full trial. Also, relating to the provision of information and education
Bowen 2002 Same trial as Bowen 2004 and Bowen 1999 but focusing on interest in genetic testing
Brain 1999 Data from same trial reported in Brain 2000a, Brain 2000b and Brain 2002 but outcome is breast self‐examination measured at baseline, prior to genetic counselling
Brain 2000b Data from same trial reported in Brain 1999, Brain 2000a and Brain 2002 looking at reasons for attending clinics
Butow 1998 Relating to the provision of information and education. Also from the same trial as Lobb 2002a and Lobb 2002b
Calzone 2005 Includes participants with a previous or current cancer diagnosis
Cameron 2001 Data from the same trial reported in Campbell 2003 and Fry 2003 but looking at GP referral rates
Campbell 2003 Data from the same trial reported in Fry 2003
Charles 2006 Includes participants with a previous or current cancer diagnosis
Cohen 2004 Data from same trial reported in Brain 1999; Brain 2000a; Brain 2002 but concerning health economics
Cull 1998 Comparing methods of delivering education
Daly 1998 Relating to the provision of information and education
Emery 2007 Relating to primary care support for GP referrals to clinical genetics, includes breast and colorectal cancer
Gray 2009 Relating to the provision of information and education. Includes women with a previous or current cancer diagnosis
Green 2001 Relating to the provision of information and education. Also from the same trial as Green 2004
Green 2004 Relating to the provision of information and education. Also from the same trial as Green 2001
Green 2005 Includes participants with a previous or current cancer diagnosis
Halbert 2010 Includes participants with a previous or current cancer diagnosis
Hall 2009 Includes participants with a previous or current cancer diagnosis
Halverson 2000 Relating to the provision of information and education. Also, participants are staff not patients
Helgeson 2001 Relating to the provision of information and education
Hopwood 2004 Not just looking at breast cancer ‐ includes bowel and ovarian cancer also
Hoskins 2001 Testing the feasibility of a RCT, not an RCT per se
Hoskins 2006 Relating to a pedigree assessment tool. No patient outcomes
Hurt 2001 Relating to the provision of information and education
Jibaja 2000 Relating to the provision of information and education
Lerman 1994 Relating to the provision of information and education. Also from the same trial as Lerman 1995 and Schwartz 1999
Lerman 1995 Relating to the provision of information and education. Also from the same trial as Lerman 1994, Lerman 1996 and Schwartz 1999
Lerman 1996 Relating to the provision of information and education. Same trial as Lerman 1994, Lerman 1995 and Schwartz 1999
Lerman 1997 Relating to the provision of information and education
Lerman 1999 Data taken from same trial as Lerman 1997 but only looking at racial differences excluding the control group
Lobb 2002a Relating to the provision of information and education. Also from the same trial as Lobb 2002b
Lobb 2002b Relating to the provision of information and education. Also from the same trial as Lobb 2002a
Miedzybrodzka 2001 Relating to the provision of information and education. Also, participants are students
Miller 2005 Includes participants with a previous or current cancer diagnosis
Miron 2000 Relating to the provision of information and education
Ormond 1996 Looking at pre‐screening education for pregnancy
Rahm 2007 Includes participants with a previous or current cancer diagnosis
Ramirez 2008 Relating to method of referral to genetics clinic. Also includes men and women and other cancers apart from breast cancer
Roshanai 2009 Includes participants with a previous or current cancer diagnosis
Roussi 2010 Includes participants with a previous or current cancer diagnosis
Schwartz 1998 Relating to the provision of information and education
Schwartz 1999 Relating to the provision of information and education
Schwartz 2001 Relating to the provision of information and education
Schwartz 2009 Relating to a decision aid for BRCA1/2 carriers rather than the provision of genetic risk information
Skinner 2002 Relating to the provision of information and education
Stoddard 2002 Meta‐analysis of randomised trials looking at mammography, not genetics
Street 1998 Education promoting breast cancer screening
Torrance 2006 Same trial as Wilson 2005. Includes participants with a previous or current cancer diagnosis
Van Roosmalen 2004a Focusing on decision aid for genetic testing rather than on service delivery ‐ also same trial as Van Roosmalen 2004b
Van Roosmalen 2004b Focusing on decision aid for genetic testing rather than on service delivery ‐ also same trial as Van Roosmalen 2004a
Venne 2007 Relating to the provision of information and education
Wade‐Walsh 2001 Relating to the provision of information and education. Also from the same trial as Watson 1996 and Watson 1998
Wakefield 2008a Refers to the use of a decision aid for genetic testing. Includes participants with a previous or current cancer diagnosis
Wakefield 2008b Refers to the use of a decision aid for genetic testing. Includes participants with a previous or current cancer diagnosis
Wang 2005 Includes participants with a previous or current cancer diagnosis
Watson 1996 Relating to the provision of information and education. Also from the same trial as Wade‐Walsh 2001 and Watson 1998
Watson 1998 Relating to the provision of information and education. Also from the same trial as Wade‐Walsh 2001 and Watson 1996
Watson 2001 Relating to the provision of information and education. Also, participants are GPs
Wevers 2011 Includes participants with a previous or current cancer diagnosis
Wilson 2005 Same trial as Torrance 2006. Includes participants with a previous or current cancer diagnosis
Wilson 2006 No patient outcomes. Participants are GPs

RCT: randomised controlled trial