Van Roey 2004.
Methods | Treatment study. Patients recruited by 6 investigators at 4 hospitals in Kampala, Uganda Loss to follow‐up: Ketoconazole ‐ 25/179 (14%) Miconazole ‐ 24/178 (13%) Analysis: no ITT |
|
Participants | Inclusion criteria: at least 18 years of age; presumed HIV positive; Life expectancy > 6 months; living within 10 km from study site; presenting with clinical signs of oropharyngeal candidiasis Exclusion criteria: patients who received antifungal therapy within 2 weeks of entry (except local treatment for vaginal candidiasis), pregnant, known history of allergy or intolerance to trial drugs; concomitant use of rifampicin, rifabutin, isoniazid, phenobarbital, phenytoin, carbamazepine, methylprednisolone, terfenadine, astemizole or cisapride; significant hepatic abnormalities. Diagnosis was by clinical examination. Presence of mycelia as observed by microscopic evaluation was documented. 357 patients enrolled 179 ‐ ketoconazole therapy 178 ‐ miconazole nitrate |
|
Interventions | Ketoconazole 400mg daily
Miconazole nitrate 10mg daily Duration: 7 ‐ 14 days |
|
Outcomes | Primary outcome was clinical response after 1 week of treatment. Clinical cure was defined as an absence of signs and symptoms (score of 0) as confirmed by the investigator. Signs and symptoms were scored by the same physician at each visit. Symptoms defined as presence (2) or absence (0) of dysphagia, oral pain and loss of taste provided a maximum score of 6. Signs (extent of oral lesions [erythema or removable white plaques]) were scored as 0 = no lesions, 1 = covering < 1 cm2, 3 = moderate covering > 1 cm2 and involving both buccal mucosa and palatal or peritonsillar regions and 4 = severe lesions with extensive involvement of buccal mucosa and palatal peritonsillar regions and pharyngeal mucosa. A subgroup analysis on clinical response was performed based on baseline CD4 count, absence/presence of dysphagia at baseline and concurrent use of broad spectrum antibiotics during the treatment phase. Relapse, amongst those clinically cured, was defined as the recurrence of at least 1 sign or symptom 14 days after treatment stopped. Adverse events: fewer drug related adverse events in miconazole group. |
|
Notes | Ethics: ethics approval obtained from AIDS research committee; informed consent obtained | |
Risk of bias | ||
Bias | Authors' judgement | Support for judgement |
Adequate sequence generation? | Unclear risk | Random allocation, method of sequence generation not reported |
Allocation concealment? | Unclear risk | Not reported |
Blinding? All outcomes | High risk | |
Incomplete outcome data addressed? All outcomes | Unclear risk | No ITT |