Table 3:

Characteristics of Included Articles in the Scoping Review of Literature on Success in Longstanding CBPR Partnerships (n=26)

First Author, Year	Partnership(s)	Partnership Research Focus/Location	Length of Partnership in years (at time of publication)	Description of Evaluation/Focus	Measures/Instruments	Reliability/Validity Data
Allen, 2013	Padres Informados/Jovenes Preparados (Informed Parents/Prepared Youth)	Positive family skills development Minnesota	6	Described a framework for partnership development and maturation based on Erikson’s eight stages of psychosocial development and provide lesson learned as the partnership moved through each stage.	None reported	N/A
Arora, 2015	Unnamed	Youth aggression prevention Multisite (U.S.)	5	Developed a measure of key dimensions of CBPR partnership development and growth.	Partnership Assessment in Community-Based Research (PAIR)	Not Provided
Arroyo Johnson, 2015	Program for the Elimination of Cancer Disparities; Padres Informados/Jovenes Preparados	Cancer disparities elimination and cancer prevention Missouri & Minnesota	5	Case study that described development of an evaluation survey of adherence to, effectiveness of, and implementation of CBPR principles in two Community Network Centers (CNPs) using CBPR.	PECaD Survey	Not provided
Baquet, 2012	Unnamed	General community health status improvement Maryland	18	Evaluated a model to increase public trust in research and enhance community and academic capacity to address community health needs through a CBPR approach.	None reported	N/A
Baquet, 2013	Eastern Shore Area Health Education Center & University of Maryland School of Medicine	Health and social issues in rural populations Maryland	23	Described key components of maintaining the partnership.	None reported	N/A
Brakefield-Caldwell, 2015	Detroit Community-Academic Urban Research Center	Health equity promotion and CBPR partnerships Detroit, Michigan	22	Described benefits, challenges and factors facilitating partnership effectiveness by 3 long-time (>20 years) community partners and affiliated partnerships.	None reported	N/A
Chambers, 2015	Patient Voices Network	Cancer prevention Buffalo, New York	19	Described the partnership’s challenges and strategies over time and recommendations for other CBPR partnerships.	None reported	N/A
Chino, 2012	The Southwest American Indian Collaborative Network	Cancer disparities in American Indians Southwest U.S.	5	Described lesson learned and work with tribal communities to build capacity in understanding and responding to cancer disparities and conducting research.	None reported	N/A
Cook, 2012	Asian and Pacific Islander American Health Forum & Association of Asian Pacific Community Health Organizations	Health disparities in Asian American, Native Hawaiian, and Pacific Islander communities Hawaii, Pacific Islands	5	Described strategies by two national umbrella organizations in leading research efforts for Asian American, Native Hawaiian, and Pacific Islander communities.	None reported	N/A
Corbie Smith, 2015	Project GRACE (Growing, Reaching, Advocating for Change and Empowerment)	HIV prevention/risk reduction in early adolescents and families Eastern North Carolina	10	Described the capacity and equity building model used to sustain Project GRACE over its 10-year history.	None reported	N/A
Ferré, 2010	Healthy African American Families	Health disparities in the African American community Los Angeles, California	20+	Described how CBPR provided the mechanism for directing power, collective action, system change and social justice in addressing community level health disparities over 3 phases of the partnership.	None reported	N/A
Goodman, 2017	Program for the Elimination of Cancer Disparities	Cancer disparities Missouri	14	Described early stage process of a quantitative measure to assess the level of engagement among community members.	Quantitative Community Engagement Measure	Internal Consistency 0.99
Goold, 2016	Deliberative Engagement of Communities in DEcisions about Research (DECIDERS)	Community engagement in CBPR Michigan, Great Lakes Region	5	Described the formative and development evaluation of the partnership over 5-year period and key domains of success related to conducting CBPR projects.	None Reported	N/A
Hicks, 2012	National Congress of American Indians Policy Research Center and Universities of New Mexico & Washington	CBPR for health disparities in American Indian and other communities Washington & New Mexico	6	Presented findings on methods and measures for CBPR research and lessons learned in their own partnership.	N/A	N/A
Hill, 2008	Douglas, Arizona Special Action Group	Diabetes prevention Douglas, Arizona	20+	Described and measures elements of the partnership’s success.	Wilder Collaborative Factors Inventory	Not reported
Jagosh, 2015	N/A	N/A		Described interviews with 24 community & academic CBPR experts to understand factors re: partnership synergy in successful long-standing CBPR partnerships.	None reported	N/A
James, 2011	The East and Central Harlem Health Outcomes Comm. Action Board	Health disparities Harlem, New York	9	Analyzed interviews with 16 current and former members of the partnership CAB and identified seven key domains that contributed to its success.	None reported	N/A
Johnson, 2009	The Philadelphia Area Research Community Coalition Connecting Solutions for Health	Health disparities in African Americans West and Southwest Philadelphia, Pennsylvania	4	Described the overall processes, developmental challenges, and accomplishments of the partnership.	None reported	N/A
Johnson-Shelton, 2015	Communities and Schools Together	Childhood obesity prevention Oregon	5	Described the partnership’s CBPR approach over time and identified 5 interacting lessons for other CBPR partnerships.	None reported	N/A
Malone, 2012	Protecting the ‘Hood’ Against Tobacco (PHAT)	Tobacco use prevention in African Americans San Francisco, California	4	Described use of a quasi-ethnographic approach to capture benefits of the CBPR partnership beyond the research itself.	None reported	N/A
Mason, 2013	Northwestern University Alliance for Research in Chicagoland Communities	CBPR capacity development Chicago, Illinois	4	Described a mixed method approach to measure community CBPR capacity building over time, identified key facilitators and challenges, and offered recommendations.	CBO CBPR Capacity/Needs Survey	N/A
Morales, 2016	University of Montana and the Confederated Salish and Kootenai Tribes	Pharmacogenetic research with American Indian and Alaskan Native populations Montana & Alaska	9	Described mixed method approach and results of a partnership self-assessment as a model to engage AI/AN partners in genetic research.	Unnamed survey	N/A
Moreno, 2009	UCLA Department of Family Medicine (UCLA DFM) and the Sun Valley Community	Asthma and diabetes prevention and access to primary care Los Angeles County, California	8	Case studies that described sustained long-term community research partnerships with UCLA Department of Family Medicine and facilitators of success.	None reported	N/A
Morgan, 2014	New Emerging Team Program (NET	Improve care for rural people with dementia Saskatchewan, Canada	11	Described the evolution of benefits and challenges over 3 phases of the partnership.	None reported	N/A
Pivik, 2011	Consortium for Health, Intervention, Learning, and Development	Child health and wellbeing British Columbia, Canada	5	Evaluated 8 CBPR partnerships within the consortium using a developed instrument to identify facilitators of academic and community partner collaboration.	The Community-Based Participatory Rating Scale	N/A
Tajik, 2007	Concerned Citizens of Tillery and the University of North Carolina SPH	Public health promotion in rural North Carolina North Carolina	10+	Examined the long-standing partnership between CCT and UNC and strategies that facilitated successful outcomes.	None reported	N/A