Skip to main content
. 2020 Apr 16;6:10. doi: 10.1186/s40795-020-00334-x

Table 1.

Descriptive summary of 15 studies on the proportion of undernutrition among HIV positive Adults in Ethiopia included for meta-analysis, 2006–2016

Study setting study year Study Design Age Response rate (%) Event Sample Size (N) Some potential biases in their methods
Humera Hospital 2012 Cross-sectional ≥20 100 159 376 Source population and study population were not defined, outcome variable was not defined, and model fitness was not checked.
Dembia District Health Centers 2015 Cross-sectional ≥18 100 105 452 Multicollinearity was not assessed and pretest was not done.
University of Gondar Referral Hospital 2007 Cross-sectional ≥15 99.7 92 331 Multicollinearity and model fitness were not assessed.
University of Gondar Referral Hospital 2016 Cross-sectional ≥18 99.4 58 319 Training for data collectors was not given and Multicollinearity was not assessed.
Mettema Hospital 2013 Cross-sectional ≥18 99.5 131 378 Multicollinearity was not assessed.
Bahir Dar Referral Hospital 2009 Cross-sectional ≥18 100 104 408 Standardized tool was not used, outcome variable was not defined, multicollinearity was not assessed and model fitness was not checked.
Addis Ababa 2006 Cross-sectional ≥18 100 128 153 Relatively has small sample size, confounders were not controlled in the statistical analysis, standardized tool was not used, pretest was not done, and training for data collection was not given.
Jimma University specialized Hospital 2014 Cross-sectional ≥18 95.6 51 109 Relatively has small sample size, non-probable sampling technique was employed to select study participants, training for data collectors was not given, and model fitness and multicollinearity were not assessed.
Jimma University specialized Hospital 2009 Cross-sectional ≥18 100 63 319 Training for data collectors was not given, model fitness was not assessed, outcome variable was not defined, and multicollinearity was not assessed.
Nekemte Referral Hospital 2013 Cross-sectional ≥15 100 115 423 The study population and source population were not clearly defined, outcome variable was not defined, and training for data collectors was not given.
Dilla University Referral Hospital 2012 Cross-sectional ≥18 100 64 520 Inclusion and exclusion criteria were not mentioned, pretest was not done, training for data collectors was not given, and model fitness and multicollinearity were not assessed.
Butajira Hospital 2014 Cross-sectional ≥18 100 77 305 Outcome variable was not defined.
Health Facilities of Hosana Town 2014 Cross-sectional ≥18 97.1 103 330 Model fitness and multicollinearity were not assessed.
In Hawassa Health Institutions 2014 Cross-sectional 20–50 99.4 119 719 Population who are not willing to participate were excluded from the study, pregnant women were included in the study and assessed using BMI this will result bias results, and model fitness and multicollinearity were not assessed.
Wolaita Sodo Teaching and Referral Hospital 2016 Cross-sectional ≥18 96.3 133 500 Exclusion criteria was not mentioned, and model fitness and multicollinearity were not assessed.