Skip to main content
. 2020 Apr 16;2020(4):CD013581. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD013581
Study Reason for exclusion
Allegrini 2009 NSAIDs used in both groups, comparison concerned only the mode of administration of the same NSAID (piroxicam patch versus cream)
Altan 2019 NSAIDs were not evaluated separately: a combination of NSAIDs and myorelaxants was evaluated
Anaya 2014 Not a RCT; clinical series
Arul Prakasam 2011 Not a RCT; prospective study, no randomisation
Berry 1988 NSAIDs used in both groups; only addition of muscle relaxant evaluated
Blazek 1986 No acute LBP; sciatica
Borenstein 1990 NSAIDs used in both groups; only addition of muscle relaxant evaluated
Bruggemann 1990 NSAIDs used in both groups; only addition of vitamins B1/B6/B12 evaluated
Buchbinder 2010 No RCT; commentary on Cochrane Review
Chrubasik 2003 No acute LBP; chronic LBP in flare
Coats 2004 No acute LBP; chronic LBP in flare
Cohen 2017 The pharmacotherapy group could use different types of medication; no subgroup analysis of NSAID users
Costantino 2011 NSAIDs used in both groups, comparison concerned only the way of administration (mesotherapeutic versus systemic administration)
Day 2013 No RCT; case report and review
Dehghan 2014 NSAIDs were used in all three groups, no comparison group without NSAIDs. Only addition of thermotherapy or cryotherapy evaluated
Dehghan 2015 NSAIDs were used in both groups, no comparison group without NSAIDs. Only addition of gabapentin evaluated
Driessens 1994 No acute LBP; chronic LBP
Eken 2014 No relevant timing of outcome assessments, follow‐up time 30 minutes (minimum follow‐up time for this systematic review is 1 day)
Evans 1980 No acute LBP; chronic LBP in flare
Friedman 2015 NSAIDs were used in all three groups, no comparison group without NSAIDs. Only addition of either cyclobenzaprine or oxycodone/acetaminophen evaluated
Friedman 2016 NSAIDs were used in both groups, no comparison group without NSAIDs. Only addition of diazepam versus placebo evaluated
Friedman 2018 NSAIDs were used in all three groups, no comparison group without NSAIDs. Only addition of either orphenadrine or methocarbamol versus placebo evaluated.
Geller 2016 NSAIDs were used in both groups, no comparison group without NSAIDs. Only addition of B vitamins evaluated.
Górska 2005 NSAIDs used in both groups; no comparison group without NSAIDs. Only addition of muscle relaxant evaluated.
Ilic 2009 NSAIDs used in both groups; comparison concerned two generic formulations of the same NSAID (nimesulide).
Ingpen 1969 No acute LBP; chronic LBP
IRCT2013052213146N2 NSAIDs were used in all groups, no comparison group without NSAIDs.
Kuhlwein 1990 NSAIDs used in both groups; only addition of vitamins B1/B6/B12 evaluated.
Lee 2008 No relevant timing of outcome assessments, follow‐up time 1 hour (minimum follow‐up time for this systematic review was 1 day).
Listrat 1990 NSAIDs used in both groups, comparison concerned only the mode of administration of the same NSAID (tenoxicam tablets versus intramuscular injections).
Matsumo 1981 No acute LBP; chronic LBP
Muckle 1986 No acute LBP; acute lumbar disc syndrome with an affected nerve root
Ostojic 2017 NSAIDs were used both groups, no comparison group without NSAIDs. Only addition of paracetamol evaluated.
Pena 1990 Information derived from a review. The original trial of Bontoux was not found. The reported data were not sufficient to be part of the current review.
Schreijenberg 2017 No study results available. Study was terminated early because of low recruitment rates.
Serinken 2016 No relevant timing of outcome assessments, follow‐up time 30 minutes (minimum follow‐up time for this systematic review was 1 day). NSAIDs used in both groups, only additional topical NSAID gel vs placebo tested.
Shell 2012 No acute LBP; chronic LBP lasting > 6 weeks, confirmed by corresponding author.
Shikhkerimov 2016 Not a RCT
Siegmeth 1978 No LBP; radiologically confirmed lumbar osteoarthritis. Presence and duration of LBP was not mentioned.
Stark 2014 Oral NSAIDs were included for blinding purposes only (N = 5).
Vetter 1988 NSAIDs were used in both groups, no comparison group without NSAIDs.
Voicu 2019 A combination of medication was used; NSAIDs were not evaluated separately.
von Uberall 2013 Not a RCT; secondary analysis on 4 non‐interventional studies on NSAIDs.
Yastrebov 2012 Not a RCT; no randomisation, intense lumbar pain syndrome, LBP not specifically mentioned.

NSAID = non‐steroidal anti‐inflammatory drug; LBP = low back pain; RCT = randomised controlled trial