Skip to main content
. 2020 Apr 2;7(4):e16993. doi: 10.2196/16993

Table 3.

Methodological characteristics of the study design and methods in the included studies.

References Study design Engagement target Primary outcome Measurement Secondary outcomes Analysis Quality rating (%)
Studies based on intervention trials


Välimäki [46]a RCTb 1:1 (TAUc) MedAdd Number of Hospitalizations Chart review Admission type, quality of life, and user satisfaction ORe and risk ratio 62

Montes et al [47] RCT 1:1 (TAU) MedAd MedAd Self-report Symptoms, insight, quality of life, and treatment attitude Stepwise linear regression 69

Xu [48] RCT 1:1 (WCf) MedAd and AppAttdg MedAd and AppAttd Pill count and scripts Symptoms and functioning Generalized estimating equation 85

Menon et al [49] RCT 1:1 (WC) MedAd and treatment attitude MedAd Self-report Symptoms and quality of life Repeated measures ANOVAh 77

Beebe et al [50] RCT 1:1:1i (NC) MedAd MedAd Pill count Symptoms ANOVA 54

Thomas et al [51] RCT 1:1 (TAU) Initial AppAttd Initial AppAttd Attendance dichotomous variable (Yes or No) Duration of untreated psychosis and symptoms OR 69

Pijnenborg et al [52] RCT 1:1 (WC) AppAttd Number of goals attained (including AppAttd) Number of appointments attended Role functioning, symptoms, cognition, and treatment attitude Multiple linear regression 31

Kravariti et al [53] RCT 1:1 (TAU) AppAttd AppAttd Number of appointments Attended N/Aj Proportions (%), OR 62

Granholm et al [54] Quasi-Experimental (NCon) MedAd MedAd, symptoms, and socialization Ambulatory monitoring Role functioning and cognition HGLMk 55
Studies based on feasibility trials

Ben-Zeev et al [42]a Feasibility TxAll User engagement Self-report User feedback Proportions (%) and paired t test 80

Aschbrenner et al [43]a Qualitative Reminder interest User interest Thematic coding of SMS text messages N/A Thematic analysis 70

Lal et al [55] Feasibility Preferred platform User interest Survey N/A Proportions (%) 80

Bogart et al [56] Feasibility (survey) MedAd User feedback Self-report N/A Proportions (%) and stepwise multilinear regression 40

Kauppi et al [44]a Feasibility MedAd and AppAttd Preferred topic Patient message selection Preferred timing Proportions (%) 60

Kannisto et al [45]a Feasibility MedAd User feedback Survey Preferred topic and platform Proportions (%) 62

aIndicates a shared sample.

bRCT: randomized controlled trial.

cTAU: treatment as usual.

dMedAd: medication adherence.

eOR: odds ratio.

fWC: waitlist control.

gAppAttd: appointment adherence.

hANOVA: analysis of variance.

iGroup allocation for this study is daily SMS text messaging only, weekly phone calls only, and a combined group (daily SMS text messaging and weekly phone calls).

jN/A: not applicable.

kHGLM: Hierarchical General Linear Modelling.