Table 5.
Comparison between the proposed method and other methods using the same dataset.
Data sets combination | Methodology | Study | Acc (%) | Our Acc (%) |
---|---|---|---|---|
A vs. E | TFA + ANN | Tzallas et al. [4] | 100 | 99.52 |
DWT + Kmeans + MLPNN | Orhan et al. [6] | 100 | ||
1-D-LBP + FT/BN | Kaya et al. [8] | 99.50 | ||
DWT + NB/KNN | Sharmila and Geethanjali [10] | 100 | ||
TQWT + KNNE + SVM | Bhattacharyya et al. [11] | 100 | ||
LMD + GA-SVM | Zhang and Chen [1] | 100 | ||
CNN + M-V | Ullah et al. [2] | 100 | ||
CWT + CNN | Turk and Ozerdem [17] | 99.50 | ||
| ||||
B vs. E | DWT + NB/KNN | Sharmila and Geethanjali [10] | 99.25 | 99.11 |
TQWT + KNNE + SVM | Bhattacharyya et al. [11] | 100 | ||
CNN + M-V | Ullah et al. [2] | 99.6 | ||
CWT + CNN | Turk and Ozerdem[17] | 99.50 | ||
| ||||
C vs. E | DWT + NB/KNN | Sharmila and Geethanjali [10] | 99.62 | 98.02 |
TQWT + KNNE + SVM | Bhattacharyya et al. [11] | 99.50 | ||
CNN + M-V | Ullah et al. [2] | 99.1 | ||
CWT + CNN | Turk and Ozerdem [17] | 98.50 | ||
| ||||
D vs. E | 1-D-LBP + FT/BN | Kaya et al. [8] | 95.50 | 97.63 |
DWT + NB/KNN | Sharmila and Geethanjali [10] | 95.62 | ||
TQWT + KNNE + SVM | Bhattacharyya et al. [11] | 98 | ||
LMD + GA-SVM | Zhang and Chen [1] | 98.10 | ||
CNN + M-V | Ullah et al. [2] | 99.4 | ||
CWT + CNN | Turk and Ozerdem [17] | 98.50 | ||
| ||||
AB vs. E | DWT + NB/KNN | Sharmila and Geethanjali [10] | 99.16 | 99.38 |
CNN + M-V | Ullah et al. [2] | 99.8 | ||
| ||||
CD vs. E | 1-D-LBP + FT/BN | Kaya et al. [8] | 97.00 | 98.03 |
DWT + NB/KNN | Sharmila and Geethanjali [10] | 98.75 | ||
CNN + M-V | Ullah et al. [2] | 99.7 | ||
| ||||
ABCD vs. E | DWT + Kmeans + MLPNN | Orhan et al. [6] | 99.60 | 98.76 |
DWT + NB/KNN | Sharmila and Geethanjali [10] | 97.1 | ||
TQWT + KNNE + SVM | Bhattacharyya et al. [11] | 99 | ||
LMD + GA-SVM | Zhang and Chen [1] | 98.87 | ||
CNN + M-V | Ullah et al. [2] | 99.7 | ||
| ||||
B vs. D vs. E | CNN | Acharya et al. [16] | 88.7 | 98.06 |
CWT + CNN | Turk and Ozerdem [17] | 98.00 | ||
| ||||
AB vs. CD vs. E | DWT + Kmeans + MLPNN | Orhan et al. [6] | 95.60 | 96.97 |
TQWT + KNNE + SVM | Bhattacharyya et al. [11] | 98.60 | ||
LMD + GA-SVM | Zhang and Chen [1] | 98.40 | ||
CNN + M-V | Ullah et al. [2] | 99.1 | ||
| ||||
A vs. B vs. C vs. D vs. E | TFA + ANN | Tzallas et al. [4] | 89 | 93.55 |
MEMD + ANN | Zahra et al. [12] | 87.2 | ||
CWT + CNN | Turk and Ozerdem [17] | 93.60 |