Table 1.
Name (Commercially Available Kits/Procedures) | FDA Approval/CE Mark | Present in EAU Guidelines 2019 | Sample | Starting Material | Technology | Type of biomarker assessed | Purpose | Overall Performance | References |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Cytology | Yes | Yes | Urine | Exfoliated cells | Giemsa an H&E staining | Cell phenotype | Diagnostic & Surveillance |
Sensitivity = 38%
Specificity = 98% |
Christopher G.T. Blick, et al. 2011 [41] |
uCyt+ | Yes/NA*1 | No | Urine | Exfoliated cells | Immunofluorescence |
Antigens/
Metabolites |
Surveillance |
Sensitivity = 73%
Specificity = 66% |
He, H. et al. 2016 [57] |
NMP22 | Yes/Yes | Yes | Urine | Exfoliated cells | Elisa | Peptides | Surveillance |
Sensitivity = 40%
Specificity = 99% |
Mowatt, G. et al. 2010 [58] |
CellSearch | Yes/Yes | No | Plasma/serum | CTC’s | Immunomagnetic enrichment | Proteins | Surveillance |
Sensitivity = 35%
Specificity = 97% |
Zhang, Z. et al. 2017 [59] |
UroVysion | Yes/Yes | Yes | Urine | Exfoliated cells | FISH |
DNA
(Aneuploidies) |
Diagnostic |
Sensitivity= 72%
Specificity = 83% |
Hajdinjak, T. et al. 2008 [60] |
BTA stat/
BTA Track |
Yes/NA*1 | No | Urine | Exfoliated cells | Dipstick immunoassay | Proteins | Diagnostic & Surveillance |
Sensitivity = 70%
Specificity = 75% |
Glas, A.S. et al. 2003 [61] |
CxBladder | No/No | No | Urine | Exfoliated cells | RT-qPCR | RNA (messenger RNA) | Diagnostic |
Sensitivity = 82%
Specificity = 85% |
O’Sullivan, P. et al. 2012 [62] |
Xpert Detection | No/Yes | No | Urine | Exfoliated cells | RT-qPCR | RNA (messenger RNA) | Diagnostic |
Sensitivity = 76%
Specificity = 85% |
Valenberg FJP, V. et al. 2017 [63] |
Uromonitor | No/Yes | Yes*2 | Urine | Exfoliated cells | Real-time PCR |
DNA
(tumor cell DNA) |
Surveillance |
Sensitivity = 74%
Specificity = 93% |
Batista, R. et al. 2019 [56] |
Epicheck | No/Yes | No | Urine | Exfoliated cells | Real-time PCR |
DNA
(methylation) |
Surveillance |
Sensitivity = 68%
Specificity = 88% |
Witjes, A. et al. 2018 [64] |
UroSEEK | No/No | No | Urine | Exfoliated cells | Massively parallel sequencing-based assay |
DNA
(tumor cell DNA) |
Diagnostic & Surveillance |
Sensitivity = 95%
Specificity = 93% |
Springer, S.U. et al. 2018 [65] |
*1 Information not available; *2 EAU guidelines refer the use of TERT/FGFR3 testing that composes Uromonitor test.