Skip to main content
. 2020 Jan 13;10(1):39. doi: 10.3390/diagnostics10010039

Table 1.

Available commercial kits performance and characteristics.

Name (Commercially Available Kits/Procedures) FDA Approval/CE Mark Present in EAU Guidelines 2019 Sample Starting Material Technology Type of biomarker assessed Purpose Overall Performance References
Cytology Yes Yes Urine Inline graphic Exfoliated cells Giemsa an H&E staining Inline graphic Cell phenotype Diagnostic & Surveillance Sensitivity = 38%
Specificity = 98%
Christopher G.T. Blick, et al. 2011 [41]
uCyt+ Yes/NA*1 No Urine Inline graphic Exfoliated cells Immunofluorescence Inline graphic Antigens/
Metabolites
Surveillance Sensitivity = 73%
Specificity = 66%
He, H. et al.
2016 [57]
NMP22 Yes/Yes Yes Urine Inline graphic Exfoliated cells Elisa Inline graphic Peptides Surveillance Sensitivity = 40%
Specificity = 99%
Mowatt, G. et al. 2010 [58]
CellSearch Yes/Yes No Plasma/serum Inline graphic CTC’s Immunomagnetic enrichment Inline graphic Proteins Surveillance Sensitivity = 35%
Specificity = 97%
Zhang, Z. et al. 2017 [59]
UroVysion Yes/Yes Yes Urine Inline graphic Exfoliated cells FISH Inline graphic DNA
(Aneuploidies)
Diagnostic Sensitivity= 72%
Specificity = 83%
Hajdinjak, T. et al. 2008 [60]
BTA stat/
BTA Track
Yes/NA*1 No Urine Inline graphic Exfoliated cells Dipstick immunoassay Inline graphic Proteins Diagnostic & Surveillance Sensitivity = 70%
Specificity = 75%
Glas, A.S. et al. 2003 [61]
CxBladder No/No No Urine Inline graphic Exfoliated cells RT-qPCR Inline graphic RNA (messenger RNA) Diagnostic Sensitivity = 82%
Specificity = 85%
O’Sullivan, P. et al. 2012 [62]
Xpert Detection No/Yes No Urine Inline graphic Exfoliated cells RT-qPCR Inline graphic RNA (messenger RNA) Diagnostic Sensitivity = 76%
Specificity = 85%
Valenberg FJP, V. et al. 2017 [63]
Uromonitor No/Yes Yes*2 Urine Inline graphic Exfoliated cells Real-time PCR Inline graphic DNA
(tumor cell DNA)
Surveillance Sensitivity = 74%
Specificity = 93%
Batista, R. et al. 2019 [56]
Epicheck No/Yes No Urine Inline graphic Exfoliated cells Real-time PCR Inline graphic DNA
(methylation)
Surveillance Sensitivity = 68%
Specificity = 88%
Witjes, A. et al. 2018 [64]
UroSEEK No/No No Urine Inline graphic Exfoliated cells Massively parallel sequencing-based assay Inline graphic DNA
(tumor cell DNA)
Diagnostic & Surveillance Sensitivity = 95%
Specificity = 93%
Springer, S.U. et al. 2018 [65]

*1 Information not available; *2 EAU guidelines refer the use of TERT/FGFR3 testing that composes Uromonitor test.